Help me pick a Peppy! (...or two!)

[daynapapaya]

I'm being very indecisive right now about my 3rd town, Pyrena. It went from being a fall town to a summer town, a decision I definitely don't regret. But now I'm struggling to narrow down who I want my peppy villager(s) will be...

The villagers I currently have that I'm definitely keeping are:

1. Margie (Normal)
2. Diana (Snooty)
3. Walker (Lazy)
4. Fang (Cranky)
5. Skye (Normal)

I know that I need a jock, Uchi, and Peppy type (no smugs in Pyrena, don't need any of the pwps).

So...

6. Jock villager. I know I'm going with Kid Cat.

7. Uchi villager. I definitely want Phoebe.

8. Peppy villager! I can't decide between...Agent S, Apple, Cherry, Cookie, Felicity, Peanut, Pinky, Pompom.

Since I then have 2 spaces left in my town for villagers, I could always adopt more than 1 of the above. But I still can't narrow down which ones I like best

Please vote on the poll, and if you are familiar with any of these peppy villagers, leave a comment with your experience, or something?

 

[artisansystem]

Both Agent S and Cookie are absolutely adorable, but looking at your current list, Cookie feels like she'd fit in more. I had her in my old town and absolutely loved her, so 10/10 would recommend, hehe.

 

[Crash]

i'd go with Felicity, i used to have her and she was wonderful ; v ;
i think she'd work well with your current villagers as well as in a summer town!​

 

[piske]

Apple! She is so gosh darn adorable xD I mean she looks like a little roly-poly red apple. Her design fits the peppy personality to a T! :>

 

[gem83]

I picked Cookie, I think she would be a good fit with the rest of your villagers! (Also, Cherry is uchi... Did you mean Cheri, the bear cub?)

 

[Ichigo.]

i recommend peanut to everyone who's trying to choose from peppies she's very cute and fitting of being a peppy. plus she's pink and has great eyeliner game. i've had her in my town since the beginning and will never let her go~

 

[daynapapaya]

I picked Cookie, I think she would be a good fit with the rest of your villagers! (Also, Cherry is uchi... Did you mean Cheri, the bear cub?)

Whoops, yes, I meant Cheri! Looks like I messed up while I was typing xD

 

[Beardo]

Pompom is such a cutie!

 

[AkiBear]

Peanut and/or Cookie.

 

[Dorian]

I chose Apple, and my second choice was Pinky

 

[piske]

I chose Apple, and my second choice was Pinky

Woot! Yay Apple!

 

[Kristen]

I've had Agent S, Cookie, Pinky, and Pompom. My favourites are Agent S and Pompom, but Pompom most. She's so cute. I had her in my town forever and now she's in my sister's town. I would definitely suggest getting her. Plus she seems to fit with the colour theme of your other villagers!

 

[roseflower]

I voted for the adorable Felicity, she has pretty eyes, the peppy villager in my town is Bianca, I?d love to recommend her >.<

 

[Miele]

I voted for both Apple and Cookie (since it gave you an option to vote for multiple). I had Apple in my town and she was the cutest lil ball of energy. If your town fruit are apples, then she's perfect for your town. Cookie is currently in my town, she moves in after Apple moved out, and I love her. She was one of my original villagers and I'm so happy that I got her back. You can't go wrong with a pink dog with anime eyes c:

 

[skarmoury]

*slams hands on table* Where is the love for dear Pinky?
Heh, but anyway, I'd pick Pinky in a heartbeat. She was my best friend in my old town, she's so cute and constantly sends me messages saying we should hang out since we're bffs and stuff like that. I love her to bits, and just thinking about her makes me miss her a lot more QuQ
I never had Felicity, but I think she's adorbs too~

 

[Fresco3332]

Go for Pinky and Pom Pom, all the others are popular and imo, not very cute, give the less popular villagers a try...

 

[HungryForCereal]

felicity and pinky are my favorite peppies

 

[Belle of Pripyat]

I like Peanut the most from the choices above.

 

[Munna]

I voted for Agent S, as I didn't really like any of those choices, so at least she is unique.

I would say go for anyone but Peanut. Peanut was the most self-involved & rude peppy I have ever met. I was so glad when she moved.

My recommended peppy is not on your list--Tangy. Tangy is a total sweetheart & very good friend. Nothing but nice things to say, and minimal reference to me as a "fan". (unlike Peanut who never really spoke of me as her friend, only as a fan..)
Tangy makes everyone walk away singing & happy.

I'd also love to see people get the Bubblegum Bunny sisters--Chrissy (peppy) & Francine (a snooty). If I had room in my town I'd love to have the pair.

Good luck in your choice!

 

[louise23]

i really like apple and Cookie