Help me decide who to kick out!

[Jared:3]

So I'm having a hard time kicking out one my villagers for somebody else, here are my villagers:
Merengue
Fang
Lily
Raymond
Diana
Mira
Ankha
Sprinkle
Marshal
Tia

I'm contemplating Merengue or Lily first because I have 3 normals already and Tia isn't leaving but I need an opinion as too who maybe should go

 

[seularin]

if it were between merengue or lily, i'd choose to kick out lily (imo i'm sorry frogo)

 

[moonolotl]

Definitely kick out a normal if you already have 3. I feel like maybe lily would fit well with your other villagers? so maybe kick merengue
Or just do a whoever asks first sort of thing like I did with my lazies. Punchy wants to leave? punchy gets to leave lol

 

[Loriii]

I'd probably move Tia or Merengue out. I prefer having one big and one small/medium-sized normal but that's just me (lol)

 

[edsett]

I like Lily more so I’d keep her. I’m in the same predicament as you - needing to kick it one of my normals aha.

 

[marea]

I vote for Lily, too. I feel like Merengue goes better with your other villagers like Marshal and Sprinkle, though that should not be the deciding factor but whether you like her or not.

 

[Dwayne Johnson]

i'd kick out Merengue, not a huge fan of her design tbh

 

[Jared:3]

I'd probably move Tia or Merengue out. I prefer having one big and one small/medium-sized normal but that's just me (lol)

Oh yea I just realized that, Merengue is the one I'm leading towards as not only do I not have a great connection with her but I feel like Lily fits in my town better

 

[Arckaniel]

I'd kick out Merengue because I'm biased and my ultimate dreamie is Lily but tbh it all depends on who you like better at the end of the day, since they're both normal personality wise they are basically just thr same just different aesthetic and vibes but choose whomever you feel more connected to

 

[Loriii]

Oh yea I just realized that, Merengue is the one I'm leading towards as not only do I not have a great connection with her but I feel like Lily fits in my town better

Personally, I like Merengue a lot. She's one of my villagers in New Leaf. I had Tia in my older town. I like her too but didn't have that much connection as I had with Merengue. I don't mind having her around though! I think I feel the same way with Merengue like how you feel having Tia around. She'd go well together with Lily. I honestly wanted Lily but I don't have space.

 

[Xara]

if it were between merengue and lily, i’d personally choose merengue ^^

 

[Cutesy]

Personally I would go with Merengue. I invited her to my island because of her unique look, but I'm not really vibing with her tbh. My other normal villagers do cute things like read books and observe nature, while Merengue is kinda just... there. Idk if you have the same experience and of course it's ultimately up to your own preferences, but that's just my two cents!

 

[Miss Misty]

Of Merengue and Lily, I'd probably choose to get rid of Merengue.

 

[tajikey]

Only know Merengue, and she shares a birthday with my wife. Naturally, my vote is to kick Lily.

 

[Alicia]

I would probably move Merengue out, I prefer Lily!

 

[Blueskyy]

I’d get rid of Merengue because I already did it on my island lol.

 

[coffee biscuit]

Lily is cuter than Merengue imo!

 

[starlightsong]

Sadly I'd say to definitely go with one of the normals I love both Merengue and Lily but I'm already getting bored of the normal dialogue just from basically always having 2 since launch since the stuff they can say doesn't seem exciting/varied enough. Personally I'm a little biased toward keeping Lily because her house is so gorgeous!

 

[Jared:3]

Im kinda getting the Merengue vibe and I think its best she goes because like said 3 normals is too many especially since I need a lazy in my town, not to mention Tia and Merengue seem similar to me not sure why but

 

[Clock]

You should move one of your normals, Merengue since you said you do not have a connection to her.