Help me decide on my dream peppy villager! Rosie or Cookie

[kerryelizabeth]

So I currently have two potentials in my second town (that I'm currently villager cycling on), and I can't decide between Cookie or Rosie... Or I could have both and just have one lazy villager. Here's my current list:

Lazy - Stitches and Erik
Uchi - Fuchsia
Smug - Lopez
Cranky - Wolfgang
Snooty - Freya and Whitney
Jock - Bam
Normal - Maple
Peppy - Rosie or Cookie

If I were to have both Rosie and Cookie, I'd let Erik go to someone else, but he's so cute! What should I do?!

 

[Zanessa]

Rosie is hard to get and Cookie is hard to find IMO. But if you must, Rosie is a cutie. You only need one peppy - take it from me. Taking in my third soon. DX

 

[clovetic]

it's a dog or cats question.

so the answer is cat. pick rosie!

 

[ShinyYoshi]

I say Cookie. She's cuter in my opinion.

 

[Chu]

I love Erik, he's in my villager and ill never let him go.

That being said, I would say keep both and let go of the lazy deer. The reason being is that you already have 3 deer.

 

[Midgetsc]

I think you should keep both.

And amg Erik. I want him so bad :O He looks like a baby reindeer.

 

[Unidentified Floor Orange]

When choosing between a kitty and non-kitty, always go with the kitty.

 

[beebs]

Eeep I picked the wrong one! Get Rosie! CAT FOREVAR!