help me decide on 2 new villagers?

[Starlight]

so i haven't played in about 6 months because one of my favorite villagers, purrl, moved away and i was sorta crushed. but over the past few days i've really been wanting to play ac again, so i actually booted it back up!!

not having purrl makes my town feel a bit empty, so now i have 2 spaces to fill
i'm trying to decide who i want to go after! i really narrowed it down, but i love so many villagers so its hard to pick 2!!

- willow the sheep (snooty)
- apollo the eagle (cranky)
- kyle the wolf (smug)
- kidd the goat (smug)

what do you guys think? any opinions are appreciated <:
thanks!

 

[Vickie]

♥ I really like Willow's design,
with her goldish fur, she looks pretty cool and cute for a sheep villager c:
I love Apollo too, I had him in WW,
and he is an awesome Cranky to have!!
He looks kinda intimidating, but after he warms up to you,
he is just a sweet guy who worries a lot.
Hope you have fun getting back into the game again c: ♥
~♚Vickie​

 

[Belle of Pripyat]

The only one I like (well, love) is Willow. I guess out of the other three, I'd choose Apollo.

 

[Blueskyy]

I think I'd go with Willow. I had Kyle and he was nothing special.

 

[MayorJudyOfZootopia]

Take Kidd and Kyle i loved Kidd when he was in my town and Kyle just looks awesome

 

[MillySoSilly]

I like Kyle so much. He was pretty awesome. I can't wait for him to move into my town. The next one would probably be Apollo. I've had him once and he was cool. I liked him a lot. The rest is meh.

 

[Paige_i_am]

Willow!!

 

[King Dorado]

go with Willow bc she's the same personality type as Purrl.

let me tell you a story. I had a villager named Lolly, the normal cat. I loved Lolly. One day when I was experimenting with time travelling, I loaded up my game and noticed that Lolly's house was gone. I had a farewell letter from her in my mailbox. I was quite dispirited about it. I got Kiki as a replacement normal cat but she wasnt quite the same. Then I got Fauna, and I can honestly say that I love Fauna even more than Lolly. So the odds are good that you will eventually find a villager you love as much or more than Purrl, and thise odds increase if you stick to the same personality type, which is why I say go with Willow.

 

[pandapples]

Willow if you want same personality type to replace Purrl. I like crankies so Apollo would be my second choice.

 

[p e p p e r]

I would pick Apollo, he looks cool & the cranky PWP are awesome

 

[Fresco3332]

I would definitely choose Kidd since his design is so cool! For the second I'd choose Apollo because he is like a grumpy old man - appearance and personality wise...

 

[Pookie4557]

I would go with Kyle because I had him in my town and had him move which I regret and his design is awesome, and Willow because she's a really awesome looking snooty.

 

[LinkToTheWorld]

For my personal favourite I would go Kyle. He's wonderful and being a smug makes him that much more loveable!
But if you want the same personality then I'd go with Willow. Although I'm not a fan of the sheep generally, I think it's their design

 

[Starlight]

thank you all for the replies so far!
i think i'm definitely gonna go with willow, because she is snooty like purrl was and her design is really really cute and bright

i think i'm just trying to decide between apollo and kyle now, since kidd is cute but i'm not too interested in him anymore
on one hand, i don't have any eagles in my town and i prefer crankies to smugs. but on the other hand, kyle just looks so awesome design wise and i love wolf villagers! gaaah so difficult to pick

 

[Deligrace]

i would pick willow and kyle!

 

[brookethecat]

I would choose Apollo and Kyle because I looove wolves <3 and Apollo's cool too

 

[Rabirin]

If you don't have another snooty, i'd suggest going for Willow. I had her in my town and she was lovely. For smug, maybe Kyle the wolf? I feel like Kidd's design pales in comparison to his. I feel like Kidd's a bit of a plain smug to be honest and his house feels a little randomly put together.

 

[wolfie1]

I'd pick Willow and Apollo. They are cute! However, if you don't have a smug, I'd choose Kyle.

 

[Fenix]

I think I'll choose Willow and Apollo, but if you want to have all the personalities, I'll choose Willow and Kidd.