help me choose my villagers?

[Loyce]

hello! i want my town to have a very woodland-fairytale theme (overdone, i know) and i'm struggling with narrowing down the villager list...i know i want every personality type (except maybe jock but i'm not sure yet) and i've chosen a few already but some personality types just have way too many villagers that i'm in love with...i'll list the villagers i like and why i want them and if anyone can give their opinions i'd be really grateful!

normal:

Spoiler

coco: fits the woodland theme. actual acnl waifu, absolutely needs to stay.
midge: fits the fairytale theme. she's cute and her catchphrase is tweedledee, a wonderland reference!
maple: fits the woodland theme. super cute and small and precious.
fauna: fits the woodland theme. another super cutie.
tia: fits the fairytale theme. teapot elephant! only drawback to tia is that i already have her and her house is in a really bad spot so i'd have to cycle for her.
lily: fits the woodland theme. i really like frogs...
merengue: fits the fairytale theme. plus her house is cafe-themed so she'd be really cute living near the roost!

peppy: bunnie is the only peppy villager i like who fits the town's theme, so bunnie is staying!

snooty:

Spoiler

diana: fits the fairytale theme. super pretty and i love deers a lot.
freya: fits the fairytale theme. actual princess.

uchi:

Spoiler

deirdre: fits the woodland theme. not actually that keen on her appearance but uchis are cool...
phoebe: fits the fairytale theme: actual phoenix she's super cool.
muffy: fits the fairytale theme: another actual princess.

lazy:

Spoiler

drago: fits the fairytale theme. actual dragon.
stitches: fits the fairytale theme. little living stuffed toy that i wanna put in my pocket.
beau: fits the woodland theme. precious cinnamon roll, too good. too pure.
clay: fits the woodland theme: he looks super cool, kinda like a statue!

cranky: again chief is the only one i like ahaha...he fits the woodland theme!
...fang is also considered for fairytale maybe but i'm not sure.

jock: genji kinda fits the woodland theme? he's literally the only jock i like so i'm not sure if i'll have a jock at all.

smug:

Spoiler

shep: fits the woodland theme. he looks like a homeless person with a guitar.
julian: fits the fairytale theme. actual unicorn.
pietro: fits the fairytale theme. gay rainbow clown ok i love him.

of course i can have ten villagers so some doubles of personality type are okay. i also wanna keep the fairytale/woodland split as even as possible. five-five would be perfect but six-four is okay too.

thank you so much in advance, this is so hard hhh...

 

[Fairytale]

I think those fit in:
Coco
Bunnie
Diana - fairytale-ish
Julian- unicorn
Lily - cute frog -love her-
Muffy lolita princess
Stitches cute stuffed teddy
Beau deer
Maple woody cutie

 

[snapdragon]

Coco, Maple, Bunnie, Freya, Muffy, Beau and Julian!

 

[Loyce]

I think those fit in:

Spoiler

Coco
Bunnie
Diana - fairytale-ish
Julian- unicorn
Lily - cute frog -love her-
Muffy lolita princess
Stitches cute stuffed teddy
Beau deer
Maple woody cutie

Coco, Maple, Bunnie, Freya, Muffy, Beau and Julian!

definitely coco, bunnie, maple, beau and julian then!
just need a snooty, uchi and a decision between chief and fang now then hhh.
and then to fill up to ten.

thank you!

 

[Psicat]

I would say go with:
Jock: Frobert
Cranky: Chief
Normal: Coco and Maple
Snooty: Diana
Peppy: Bunnie
Smug: Julian
Uchi: Phoebe
Lazy: Beau and Drago

 

[Loyce]

I would say go with:

Spoiler

Jock: Poncho or Genji
Cranky: Chief
Normal: Coco and Maple
Snooty: Diana
Peppy: Bunnie
Smug: Julian
Uchi: Phoebe
Lazy: Beau and Drago

i reallly don't like poncho ahaha..not really a fan of jocks in general actually!
but that's a great lineup aaa...though i might swap out genji for a second fairytale-themed villager to keep it even..

thank you!

 

[Psicat]

i reallly don't like poncho ahaha..not really a fan of jocks in general actually!
but that's a great lineup aaa...though i might swap out genji for a second fairytale-themed villager to keep it even..

thank you!

Well you also said you liked frogs, even though it was in reference to Lily, you could try one of the jock frogs then. Frobert is cute or Cousteau. They fit a woodland theme nicely and in some ways a fairytale theme as well, since you could see them as a Frog Prince.

 

[Loyce]

aaa yeah i forgot about frobert, he is actually really cute! definitely have to consider him then, thanks for reminding me he existed!
and yes i do love frogs, lily is just my favourite in the game ahaha..

 

[abbydoll]

Normal : Maple
Peppy : Bunnie
Snooty : Diana
Uchi : Deirdre
Lazy : Drago
Cranky : Fang
Smug : Shep
Jock : Genji

Just my opinion! c:

 

[Classygirl]

From that list and only that list, I won't make any peppy suggestions..If you have Tia and house placement is that big of a deal, then don't bother cycling out 16 to get her back, it's one of those if you wanted her bad enough you wouldn't go through that things..so Maple I adore as well as fauna and think fauna would be best for nature..now Diana and Freya are both it keepers to me. I would also pick Drago over the others anyway and Julian from that list though to tone down fairy tale Shep doesn't really fit natural but he is good too. As far as uchis I really dislike Diedre, the other two Muffy who is a little gothic and Pheobe who is really cool..I like all the uchis that are deer or sheep or Pheobe, lol...aside Diedre. Pashmina and Fuschia are cool deer though. I love all cranky wolves,Lobos eyes make him stand out but they are all good, as far as Jocks the only one I ever liked really was Sparrow and e is woodlands and funny also a PWP machine very often overlooked. Don't know if that helps at all but as far as Diedre I don't think I am the only one who thinks she is a little boring and stays in a lot as opposed to other uchis who are outgoing though her home is nice Pashmina would be my deer replacement pick or pink and cute Fuschia.

 

[RainyCat]

I really do like Fauna and Lily, Fauna is cute. I'm biased but Fang is my favorite, because his house and color. His house is nicer than Chief's imo His page on wiki says he likes sneaking though snow. Look



Invisible(ish) Fang XD not even the best photo of him. Ok, maybe I should stop advertising Fang :3

Freya isn't really a princess(I thought so too), she's a rock star. Her house is entirely rock themed. May not fit theme, but she's a favorite of mine, I definitely recommend Freya. Oh and Julian and Pietro can be fabulous together, ahh decisions! Julian fits the theme though. I have Phoebe (lol I have all of them) and her house is beautiful and she is awesome

 

[Sonny Resetti]

I think those fit in:
Coco
Bunnie
Diana - fairytale-ish
Julian- unicorn
Lily - cute frog -love her-
Muffy lolita princess
Stitches cute stuffed teddy
Beau deer
Maple woody cutie

Typical dreamiest. *sigh*

 

[rosabelle]

Snooty-Diana (woodland)
Uchi-Deirdre (woodland)
Lazy-Drago (Fairytale)
Smug-Julian (Fairytale)
Normal-Coco and Lily

I tried balancing out the woodland and fairytale types lol

 

[tokkio]

I'd pick: coco, maple, tia, phoebe, diana, drago, julian..

well actually everyone you listed all really fits your theme! i love the theme btw! but idk i guess i really think the villagers who most fit the theme are the ones I listed eheh

 

[Loyce]

thank you everyone! i've decided on my ten now though, i read all of your reasons and stuff and chose;
coco, maple, lily, phoebe, chief, diana, drago, julian, stitches and bunnie!

however i am gonna bring in a jock for a bit to get the instrument shelter pwp, and i'm considering genji, frobert and sparrow for that,,and i might end up keeping them who knows! (but the jocks really do annoy me ahaha...)