Help me choose my Peppy villager

[Clavis]

Tammi having left me, i'm in need of a Peppy villager to replace her !
I'd like her to be somehow related to my town theme (Pink-Yellow, Sweets/Fairytale.) (If you know Puella Magi then it's based on Charlotte's world)

I was thinking on :

-Tangy the Cat, because she is cute and related to the town by literally being fruit
-Sprinkles the penguin, because she is like icing on cake and also very nice
-Penelope the mouse, because the bow ers are so fricken cute, and her colors fit in perfectly
-Wendy the Sheep, because of her scarf (even if that'll eventually change :c)

Feel free to suggest any other Peppy villager that could suit my town .

 

[MightyMunchlax]

You could get Bunnie or Felicity or Peanut.

 

[Karminny]

I think Felicity could go

 

[Clavis]

Bunnie and Peanut are good, thanks ! i really don't like the look of Felicity tho sorry
I thought of Flora aswell perhaps.

 

[kuseiro]

For your Puella Magi theme (Charlotte's world), I find that Penelope is definitely the best option imo because of her color scheme and the bow! It definitely reminds me of Charlotte's (hair???) design!

I'd also like to say that your town theme is really cool xD

 

[Hypno KK]

I wouldn't pick Tangy or other fruit-based villagers... while they could technically fit the sweets theme, I think it'd be a little weird, plus out of them I think Tangy is really popular and it would be nice to see more variety (like how Nibbles is a watermelon).

Sprinkles is really cute, I agree! Penelope is really underrated and I love her so I'd pick her out of these.

Annabelle and Twiggy are yellow and I think they'd look nice. Patty's catchphrase is based on a nursery rhyme so she'd be great for a fairy tale town.

If you're stuck, maybe you could look at their house exteriors and see which one would look best in your town.

 

[Clavis]

For your Puella Magi theme (Charlotte's world), I find that Penelope is definitely the best option imo because of her color scheme and the bow! It definitely reminds me of Charlotte's (hair???) design!

I'd also like to say that your town theme is really cool xD

Thanks ! I can show you some screenshots when i get a few more things set up !

I wouldn't pick Tangy or other fruit-based villagers... while they could technically fit the sweets theme, I think it'd be a little weird, plus out of them I think Tangy is really popular and it would be nice to see more variety (like how Nibbles is a watermelon).

Sprinkles is really cute, I agree! Penelope is really underrated and I love her so I'd pick her out of these.

Annabelle and Twiggy are yellow and I think they'd look nice. Patty's catchphrase is based on a nursery rhyme so she'd be great for a fairy tale town.

If you're stuck, maybe you could look at their house exteriors and see which one would look best in your town.

I agree completely on the variety thing, and yeah Penelope is definitly underrated ! (Also i love your name Hypno KK is the best song ever)

-
I think i'mma go with Penelope now cause she's really cute and she fits and for another obscure reason (The theme song of the world i'm basing my town on is called "Wo ist die kase" which translates to where is the cheese so a mouse is good haha. Thank you everyone .

 

[ams]

I had Sprinkle for a while and I adored her!

 

[Bosca]

Honestly so many peppys are great, if it wasn't for my obsession with Tangy and not wanting to have too many similar personality types I'd have like 10 of them lol. Would you consider Flora? Flamingos are kind of fairytale like, if you think of Alice in wonderland.

 

[Chipped-Teacup]

Bonbon? She's brown, but like you can get Bonbon sweets . Plus Peanut is in the 'Animal Crossing: Sweets Day' mini game in Nintendo Land, so she fits well too

 

[misspiggy95]

For my Peppy villager I love Flora, she is so adorable! Plus she is a Flamingo, so she is pink!

 

[Clavis]

Too many great Peppy's , and they're supposed to be one of my least preffered types haha. My top 3 atm are Penelope Flora and Sprinkle !

 

[00ToxicLove00]

I say Pecan she's super adorable.

 

[Eve]

Chrissy and Cookie are adorable too. But I think if you really love those three, then do Penelope. She's adorable, and you'll love her once you get her (I had her in my town for a year and was heartbroken when she left).

 

[oreo]

Sprinkle definitely! I like Cookie, Bunnie, and Wendy too! Wendy looks cute even without the strawberry scarf. c:

 

[supercataleena]

Chrissy and Cookie are adorable too. But I think if you really love those three, then do Penelope. She's adorable, and you'll love her once you get her (I had her in my town for a year and was heartbroken when she left).

I agree with this. Chrissy would really fit with Charlotte's witch look. But yeah, Penelope would be the choice I'd pick from your options. She's adorable and is perfect for what you're going after.

 

[Clavis]

I say Pecan she's super adorable.

Pecan's snooty haha, and in my void count :'(

Thanks for everyones input i'm definitly going for Penelope, too adorable to resist !

 

[buzzing]

oh my goodness, sprinkle is like, my number one favorite peppy next to puddles
i say sprinkle

edit/addition: but penelope is super cute too! lol

 

[erikaeliseh]

my favourites are cookie and rosie, but from your list i think sprinkles is so cute! but i think cookie fits a fairytale theme really well, i see her in a lot of towns like that

 

[seigakaku]

OHH wendy is such a cutie!! i never see her in any towns either ;v;