Genji is amazing. I love the inside and outside of his house, and he's a lot less like a typical jock because of his appearance I feel. Dom is really cute too though. And even though they aren't on the list, Antonio and Iggly are other favorite jocks of mine so I thought I should mention them. Good luck on your decision!
Genji’s my guy, my main man, and my best bud, so have to vote for him. I love his kind of grumpy face. He is, as someone mentioned, very specifically stylized, so if you have a theme island I can see he might not always fit in.
Have to throw in that if we are talking cat jocks, I’d say stinky > kid Kat. He’s so cute and the jock fits his whole weird wrestling vibe (his catchphrase is ‘GAAHH’, which is awesome.
also not on your list but I think biff is very cute.
I’m biased against the ‘superhero’ villager looks though, from rocket to kid Kat to Mira, to whatever the squirrel one is, so there is that.
I picked Dom but had Genji in New Leaf. Visited someone for a diy and met Genji on their island, he is still very precious. I actually like some of the none-popular jocks too, like Samson. I think they are all sweet.
I love dom, roald, and genji bc they y’all all buff but when you look at them, two of them are very fluffy and the other is just small and adorable. I love it when jocks act like jocks but we all secretly know they aren’t
I actually just swapped dom for bam! Bam is super cute and I love the deer but he was too much of a bro for me.
Rudy and his stupid silly face for me. But he’s not on your list so I voted Genji instead. He’s cool and he’s got a nice house. I love his house interior and exterior especially at night when his red lantern lights up against his purple roof. It’s very nice.
Genji because his house is just AMAZING interior AND exterior, although, I prefer Boone as my Jock villager because he's the only Gorilla design I REALLY do like lol
I pick Kid Kat because he has a cute design and because he’s a cat.
If I could vote other, I’d say Rudy. Rudy has grown on me so much. I love him so much now in spite of the muscle talk that I don’t really like. lol . This is your town though, so, you should pick whichever has the design that appeals to you more.
DOM. He's so funny and cute! And he looks like the pleading emoji.
I had Kid Cat before I got Dom and idk what it was but my Kid Cat was kind of boring? He only ever talked about jock stuff and never really interacted with my other villagers...Dom on the other hand came and stole someone's catchphrase on the first day and he's always walking/running around looking CUTE. I much prefer Dom's house exterior too personally. Matches with my island better also.
I voted for Roald! He’s a cute little penguin, I love the interior of his house and the exterior is very gorgeous!(Plus, he has those big creepy eyes )