Kid Cat is the best in my eyes for simple reason of being a caat- jk!
I don't really like jocks, honestly. But kid cat and his general theme is very childish to me, so he gives me less workout-alohic vibes and more overly enthusiastic little kid showing you his baseball cards if that makes sense
Genji is great. I love his unique appearance and his expressions are great. He looks cute and cool at the same time. His house exterior and interior is probably one of the best in the game.
Don't love jocks much, but I do like Genji. He's quite stylised which can be a good or bad thing depending on if you're going for a certain theme. House interior is great. His catchphrase is mochi which I really like for some reason.
Also love his default expression, so grumpy. It clashes with his personality a bit but I made a habit of not talking to jocks so I can suspend disbelief a bit and pretend he's stoic.
Bam is really adorable. Honestly, his only downside is his house interior.
But I think he's absolutely precious and seeing him around my island makes me happy
plus...I'm a sucker for deer villagers. haha
For me, Roald or Bam. Chose Bam because he looks outdoorsy and energetic... Roald is good because he doesn't look like a jock at all.
I have Boots on my island. I like him. Sly, too. And Teddy was one I didn't pay much attention to, wasn't a fan of the big bears, but after having him in Pocket Camp, he is also pretty cute. I would go with whoever fits your island best.
Among the options, Bam is the most jock-looking villager.
Kid Cat is playful and fun.
Tank is also great. He's a rhino and he's the bulkiest among the options.
Dom is just too fluffy for my taste... in jock standards. But I just imagine him being muscular under all that fleece.
Roald... I like him. He's great. A meme.
I had Kid Cat as my starter jock and really miss him! He is so much fun and so cute! He always brightened my day because no matter what he had a smile on his face and encouraging words to say, even if was about working out lol
I 2nd Pierce (and Teddy isn't half bad either). More of a Sterling girl but if I'm putting my personal bias aside Pierce is pretty good for a jock, especially if you're a fan of Eagles.
If I had to pick one on the poll, though... Probably Roald.