Depending on if you have a Peppy or Jock villager, that's what I always decided on first.
But I'd prefer Bam~
My starter Jock villager, he's a cool guy, only second to Genji imo.
Had Flora in my cycling town and she stayed there for a pretty long time, and she was my Peppy starter there as well. And same goes for my main town, to which she plotted her house in the middle of my path smh thanks m80