I don't really like either and I don't have either currently, but I'd pick classic over modern every time. It looks less ridiculous and unnatural to me. I accidentally voted for modern on the poll though, whoops
I chose the classic. I wanted to go next to my caf? and I thought they'd clash if I had the modern. Plus, my town was pretty wooden-looking at the time and if I had that metal thing it'd look ridiculous. I didn't know about the whole Booker/Copper thing but I would've preferred Copper -.- oh well.
I picked the modern one. I feel like the classic one wouldn't fit my town so well. I use a lot of street lamps (The PWP) in my town and seeing those next to a classic police station, wouldn't work well in my opinion. I also like modern just because it is not made out of wood. c:
I was a little surprised too at the poll results. I thought it wouldn't be this close (although now it's 23 - 18 ). I still thought a significant majority of players would pick the modern one.
I wish they would have done a fairytale and a zen design for the station. That would have been awesome. I chose the modern one because I've always preferred Cooper over Booker.