I consider myself extremely lucky with getting random villagers. Right off the bat I got Robin and Apollo (my two all-time WW favorites) as starters. Genji and Rosie both moved in without resetting and I adore them both. Bob was another villager who moved in on his own accord, but we never clicked, you know?
Curt and Flora are currently two of my favs. Curt because... I am obsessed with making him put asian stuff in his house to make him like a nerdy anime fan XD. Flora.... because she's an effin Flamingo!