My favorite from the start until now is Carmen. She's a peppy rabbit. I love everything about her. She's cute and fun to watch, so I do stalk her quite a bit. I also talk to her ALL the time, because she makes me smile, and even literally lol often. In fact, in my first letter to her, I wrote "sorry I talk to you so much" and that was within the first week of playing the game. After a year, I'm sure I've talked to her a thousand times already. XD
She just makes me feel good and brightens the day and makes the town fun. I can't rave about her enough. She's the one I go to when I need to find out who's leaving. She tells me right away. She also gives me tons of free crap every time I talk to her. Which was really nice when I was building up my catalog.
I don't know why she's not more popular. Do people realize she's a chocolate bunny? IDK, food-related villagers are usually popular. And with her looks and personality, I can't find a reason why she's not Tier 1 or 2. Very odd. Well, she's #1 in my eyes. <3
Hmm... Well filbert is my all time fav EVER and he's in my main town, birdsong. I'd prob have to go with Bunnie in storybrk though even though filbert is in that town as well for the time being. I reset that town a couple of weeks ago and he ended up as one of my starting 5. I'll eventually find him a great home though, so if anyone knows anybody looking for sweet little filbert, shoot me a pm