Favorite Spooky Set variants

[Aurita]

Orange is a classic & it’s my favorite one for pretty much all the spooky furnitures. But I do like the monochrome version of the spooky standing lamp & spooky candy set! Orange just screams Halloween to me haha

even though orange is my fav, I tried to use a mix of the other colors on my island so it doesn’t get too stale

 

[Balverine]

I love the monochrome!
my least favorite is the yellow pumpkin variant for most items, because I really don't feel that pastels fit the halloween feel lol

 

[RedPanda]

I go back and forth between orange, black, and green, but generally I prefer the orange as it feels more Halloweeny. The black feels more goth/horror. But I really like them all. The yellow is probably my least favorite but it's still pretty cool!

 

[John Wick]

The monochromatic arch looks good!

 

[Kattea]

I love white pumpkins! My town uses alot of white log stakes and white flowers so they fit in perfectly! If only they weren't so hard to grow..

 

[GnarlyGarden]

I’m using all with orange being most common, then white, green, and yellow least often ( on many items it just looks like faded orange.)

If you are having trouble getting more of a particular color, remember that you can plant the pumpkins, and that plant will grow the color of the pumpkin you planted. So to get more whites, plant white pumpkins, etc.

 

[Dunquixote]

So far I’m using yellow and orange. I do like the monochrome; I just kinda wish we could customize the tree to be brown and not white.

 

[Hypno KK]

I like pretty much all of them! The default always look great and the others depend on the item.

 

[Xara]

my favourite is the yellow variation! yellow usually isn’t my favourite anything but it just looks so good. i was definitely expecting white/monochrome to be my favourite but the yellow is just,, *chefs kiss*

 

[Hilbunny]

Yellow goes nicely with my yellow brick

 

[Khaelis]

Honestly, I like them all. Though, I like a fair bit of the green ones the most.

 

[Che5hire Cat]

I love the monochrome variations the most, followed by the classic orange ones. I'm not such a huge fan of the green versions however, they are not really appealing to me.

 

[Bugs]

I work as a green grocer irl and we've just got our pumpkins in, I love the variety represented in new horizons, and my favourite pumpkin is the white ones (sometimes called Casper or Ghost pumpkins by the way!) I love the green and white variations of the pumpkin furntirue they go well in my spooky forest room

 

[CherieBits]

My personal favorite is the yellow variant, primarily because it's the "pastel" version of the set! Most noticable in the candy set and the garland!

 

[moonlights]

orange is my fav. but I think some colours look better on certain pieces of furniture. like I love the spooky tower in monochrome bc it maintained a somewhat orange colour, but I think the monochrome lantern looks bad. overall though I think they did a great job with the variants. if I had to pick a fav variant it would be a toss up between yellow and monochrome!

 

[Vintage Viola]

I also like the monochrome, for the same reason you listed. I’d rather leave everything in the original orange though, it feels more “in spirit” of the holiday.

 

[Catto]

I’m using all of them too! I just love flashy Halloween themed stuff in general so I want to FILL my island with everything or every color

 

[litilravnur]

I agree with @deirdresgf, I prefer the orange pumpkins because they look more natural and the other colors look a bit strange. I love that there are different faces on pumpkins for each color variation but I would have preferred that color and faces were separated features for customization

 

[annex]

I'm always drawn to the classic orange.

 

[hakutaku]

Like many, I like the classic orange the best. They just look the best, especially since they're in an orange/yellow-themed area on my island!