Brewster! I love that guy! I can't put my finger on exactly why, though. When I first started playing, I was pretty much convinced that he was a pickle. I KNOW, he's supposed to be a pigeon, which makes more sense than a pickle, seeing how the villagers and shopkeepers are all actual animals, but look at him! He's green!
My boyfriend was working a convention last October (Youmacon, I think? Is that in Detroit in October?) and picked up a nice-sized plushie of Brewster the Pickle and gave him to me for Christmas. He now sits on a little shelf above my bed, watching over me as I sleep.
Cyrus is my favorite, but I also really like Reese. I just really like them together. They're both adorable and have cute married personalities. I've even done a Cyrus cosplay before, haha.
I love Blathers and Leif (I voted Blathers as Leif is not on the list. No biggie, though!) Blathers is just such a sweetheart. I love how he always falls asleep in the daytime and has a fear of insects.
I can't decide between Blathers and Brewster. I love coffee, which kind of automatically makes me like Brewster. But Blathers has been my favorite for forever, and I just adore the museum (both in the game and ones in real life) So for that I think I'd pick Blathers.
Sable. At first, talking to her to unlock the QR machine seemed like a chore. But the more I talk with her, the more I enjoy what she has to say. A year later, and I still find an occasional new dialogue.