Favorite Reese's Peanut Butter Cup??

[Peachtree53]

I recently ate the Chocolate Lover's and Peanut Butter Lover's cups and my favorite was the Peanut Butter Lover's cup

 

[Xeleron]

More of a Hershey's person myself lol but I prefer the traditional version

Edit: I meant to say Hershey's cookies n' cream (Hershey's company makes both hershey's bars and reese's peanut butter cups lol)

 

[xTech]

Despite seeing them everywhere and my cousin having an obsession with them, I have never eaten anything from reese's, be they his buttercups or pieces. I also have never tried peanut butter. I know it might sound crazy, but the idea of peanuts being crushed into a spread just doesn't sound very good to me, and don't even talk to me about putting that spread inside a chocolate .

 

[Corrie]

Whoa!! Why does America get all the cool flavours?! Implying they're only in America, that is. Eitherway I've never seen them. They look amazing!! The Peanut Butter Lover looks the best to me.

I also love the ones with the Reeses pieces inside the middle!

But honestly every Reese is the best. Best chocolate ever!

 

[Dio]

Despite seeing them everywhere and my cousin having an obsession with them, I have never eaten anything from reese's, be they his buttercups or pieces. I also have never tried peanut butter. I know it might sound crazy, but the idea of peanuts being crushed into a spread just doesn't sound very good to me, and don't even talk to me about putting that spread inside a chocolate .

I used to think you were cool but now I don’t know what to think of you anymore how dare you say that

Whoa!! Why does America get all the cool flavours?! Implying they're only in America, that is. Eitherway I've never seen them. They look amazing!! The Peanut Butter Lover looks the best to me.

I also love the ones with the Reeses pieces inside the middle!

But honestly every Reese is the best. Best chocolate ever!

I never even knew there was a different flavor other than regular here I never saw them lol

Canada has Mr. Big Bar though and that’s probably my favorite candy bar I ever had

 

[Plume]

None of the above. Reese's eggs or christmas trees are the superior reese!

 

[mayortiffany]

None.

I don't like peanut butter, so I don't think I'd care for any of the Reese's cups. I'm not allergic or anything, I've just never really seen the appeal in it? It was always in the house since my Dad likes it, but I never asked for it. I vastly prefer cashew or almond butter.

I'd be curious about what a Reese's Almond Butter Cup would taste like though. Or, what about a Reese's Hazelnut Spread Cup?

 

[Corrie]

I used to think you were cool but now I don’t know what to think of you anymore how dare you say that



I never even knew there was a different flavor other than regular here I never saw them lol

Canada has Mr. Big Bar though and that’s probably my favorite candy bar I ever had

Mr. Bigs are great! I used to always pick that at the marina my cottage was near because it was the biggest bar there lol.

 

[Vanida]

I never tried one. They are very hard to find in Australia

 

[LadyDestani]

I haven't tried the Peanut Butter Lover's or Chocolate Lover's but I'm going to go with traditional because that's my favorite of all the other kinds I've tried. Even the different sized Reese's cups don't taste the same to me because of the chocolate to peanut butter ratio. I'll still eat them, of course, but the traditional cups in the standard size are my favorite.

 

[Uffe]

Regular. They're the best when frozen.

 

[Midoriya]

Definitely the regular. Don’t need any extra flavor to them as I find them to be pretty good.

 

[Halloqueen]

I've never tried the Chocolate Lover's or Peanut Butter Lover's variations of Reese's. If I were to try one, the Chocolate Lover's sounds more appealing.

As such, I'm voting for the regular Reese's Cups.

 

[Xara]

i’ve only ever had the regular ones and so i voted for those - they’re a classic but so, so good. and while not one of the options, the white chocolate ones are so, so good. i’m not usually a huge fan of white chocolate but those make me

 

[Seastar]

I actually just love all of them. I voted for regular, though.
I'm also surprised the white chocolate ones aren't in the poll?

 

[Pintuition]

Regular! The extra chocolate or extra peanut butter ones end up being two overpowering. The regular is balanced the best! I also really like the regular mini ones!

 

[xlisapisa]

I’ve never tried the new ones, if I did I probably would choose chocolate over peanut butter. But since I’m basic, i voted for regular. Nothing beats the original.

 

[Your Local Wild Child]

I go wild with any kind of Reese’s cup (it’s my favorite chocolate) but I’ve only tried the original out of all the ones you’ve listed.

 

[Imbri]

Why mess with a good thing? The original is just fine.

 

[KrazyKarp]

Just the regular/original is the best. But any Reese's is fantastic!