Sherb is such a cutie. I’m a little biased now since I have him in my town, but he and audie were the only new designs I really liked right at the start. Dom grew on me though. I love his silly expressions.
I never cared about the monetary value of villagers, in my opinion, it's a little silly to just focus on that aspect, but out of all the new villagers, I do really like Sherb. He was my random lazy move in and has since lived on my island, and I think he's adorable. I love his baby blue colour with his pink cheeks. I think they definitely did a wonderful job of designing him, and I'm pretty happy to have him on my island!
I really like Sherb and Audie, probably because I have them in my town and I love their design. Sherb is adorable and Audie is so stylish! I didn't really like Cyd that much when I had him in my town. I have Reneigh in my town and I like her, just not as much as Audie or Sherb. I think I will really like Raymond when/if i get him in my town.
I’m not familiar with any of the new villagers except Megan who was game provided ( villager 3, 4 or 5). She’s an absolute sweetheart with great facial expressions (her sad face will break your heart). I know she not a favorite for many people, but I find she’s great to interact with and you often feel she’s about to give you a big hug. You don’t feel that from many of the villagers. She’s also a lot of fun to dress. Here’s my current favorite...
My genuine favorite new villager is probably Reneigh - she's the only one of the bunch that I feel like I'll still like just as much once the hype dies down. In the maybe category is Audie and Sherb, both of whom I like but might grow more apathetic to as time goes on.