I think I know why last year’s eggs became rare. It’s because we had 12 eggs to choose from when purchasing. When you have a smaller selection to choose from, and everyone has a lot to spend, there’s going to be more of each in circulation. But with how many eggs we got to choose from last year, we didn’t have as many of each in circulation.
My advice is that we can have the two-basket gimmick again only with the first year or two after the next Animal Crossing game comes out. After that, we should go down to one basket every year, until AC7 comes out. Then the cycle repeats.
Meanwhile, it doesn’t hurt to rerelease older egg collectibles every once in a while. I’m glad that the Disco Ball Egg got a second spin during the 2024 Egg Hunt. But they should randomly pick three to six retro eggs every year (preferably the ones released in 2016, 2017, 2018, or 2019) and put it in the shop along with some new eggs. I would also like to see other Easter collectibles besides just eggs.
I love the idea of having something else besides the eggs, for example little Peeps collectibles in different colours
As far as how many should be released or re-released I'm not familiar enough with the egg hunts yet, or with the collectibles market, to judge but I usually look favourably on re-releasing older stock in small/limited quantities