Eat it, burn it or keep it (≧∇≦)b

[Chicha]

Burn

a banana

 

[Kirbystarship]

Eat it.

ball of paint.

 

[MochiACNL]

keep it.

a box with a cat in it

 

[Kirbystarship]

Keep it.

Lots of bombs

 

[Kip]

Keep it ( /'v'\ )

Expired cake mix

 

[LuminousLisa]

Burn it...

A stale piece of bread...

 

[namiieco]

Keep it, obviously

My dog

 

[LuminousLisa]

Keep it

A penny

 

[Bunnilla]

keep it

a disabled pet

 

[AnimalCrossingPerson]

Eat it.

Bleach.

 

[Daydream]

Burn

A rotten fruit?

 

[Antonio]

Keep

Jar of souls

 

[AnimalCrossingPerson]

Keep?

Spoiler: May be a bit heavy for this forum - don't get triggered.

A deceased relative.

 

[namiieco]

I don't know what else someone would do other than burn it.

Some grapes with an unactivated bomb in one of them.

 

[Buttonsy]

Keep it, burning it might set it off!!

A jar of worms

 

[namiieco]

Burn it

A vanilla cheesecake with a bite taken out of it

 

[Buttonsy]

Burn it, I cannot eat food that has been bitten by someone else...

A bag of milk

 

[namiieco]

Burn it

A leaf that your friend says tastes good

 

[Buttonsy]

Eat it unless it was off the ground

A plushie that is half of your favourite villager and half of your least favourite villager (like half and half right down the middle)

 

[namiieco]

Keep

A lemon