I have 2 normals, 2 snootys, than 1 of each of the rest of the personalities If you go up to 10 villagers your gonna have to repeat a personality eventually
I had five peppies in my main town at one time(Tangy,Bubbles,Bangle,Bianca and Pippy)but even with that many I didn't get tired of them.That did happen,though,when I had three lazies(Beau,Ozzie and Joey) all living in the same part of my town.Joey and Beau had slightly different dialogue but Ozzie seemed to just repeat what the other two said.
As much as i love the normals and think they are the cutest, i couldnt stand to have so many spouting the same things lol
I like to have atleast one of each
Yesterday I had 3 cranky personalities. So I had to let one go: Avery. Seeing as I have another cranky as a dreamie I'm likely going to let Bruce go at some point.
Also have two peppy now, Felicity and Annabelle. Also happened yesterday.
edit: Oh yeah and I have three jocks too. Teddy, Genji, & Peck
The things they say/do and how they interact with other villagers is based on their zodiac too, and to a lesser extent, their species. Agnes and Phoebe are both uchi, and with birthdays a day apart: they're practically the same person, it's awful. Tangy and Bianca are 6 months apart, and they act fairly different. Same with Elvis and Chief (when I had him), they had overlapping dialogue but different... attitudes, I guess?
I also had 3 normals once (Daisy, Tia, Pekoe), and it was too much IMO. Particularly normals, as they're, well... bland. Two lazies or two crankies has always been fine for me c: my dream line up has 2-3 lazies. It really depends on how much you like that personality.
i had 4 crankies in my town until i let my two favorites move out ;~; but they all say the same things, so i had to let them go so now i have octavian and vic left
then i have 1 smug (eugene)
1 jock (ribbot)
1 uchi (phoebe)
1 normal (savannah)
2 lazies (cranston and zucker)
I have one for each personality except for smug(I have 2 smugs).
Then again, I noticed that Jacques and Marshal have a slight difference on their dialogue(although they sometimes say the similar things).
For example, Jacques sometimes mentions K.K. songs, something that Marshal never said to me.
I'm gonna have 4 cranky villagers(Chief,Wolfgang,Fang,Lobo) when I finally move all my wolf villagers to my new main town. 2 snooty(Whitney, Freya) and 1 smug(Kyle) and 1 normal(Skye).
I have two normals (Savannah and peaches) and two snooties (Annalise and Ankha) and idk, they seem pretty different to me. I don't notice them repeating the same things as each other very often.