Do you have any villagers you wanted that you regretted once you got them?

[Etown20]

i have said this before and i'm gonna say it again lol
i found sherb the other day, and anyone who knows me knows that i am so easily scared haha
sherb was one of my dreamies so when i found him i obviously invited him straight away
but after entering his house i noticed he had hypno k.k. playing and that song freaks the heck outta me and i started hearing it in my sleep so 2 days later i had him off my island, not soon enough though

I ended up gifting Sherb another song to try and replace it. He was playing the new song last time I was in his house, but not sure how often they change their music up after you gift them new songs.

 

[SliceAndDice]

Well not in New Horizon, but in City Folk I had Rod and was so happy, because I restarted many times to get him. But after a while he got on my nerves, always asking me for Rare Fish I couldn’t possibly catch for him. It got worse over the time and soon it became a daily task which I couldn’t finish. At this moment, I wished I could get rid of him.

Hahaha, I had the exact same problem with Rod, but in Wild World. It made me dislike him quite a bit.

 

[telluric]

When I heard about the new villagers, Audie looked soooo cute to me!! She's adorable, and I love wolf villagers. And peppys are adorable. I got her in a (pretty cheap, thankfully) trade pretty early in the game and I was happy to have her. Once I started talking to her, she pretty much only gave me dialogues i had heard exactly from my first peppy villager, Pate. I wasnt too keen on Pate at first but she grew on me so much after I got her and we eventually became besties. So Audie just feels kind of off for me.. I still have her, and love her because her design is so nice. But ive found myself considering trading her which i didnt really expect. So I dont totally regret getting her, but she didn't live up to all my expectations...

 

[tonkuri]

i found kid cat on a mystery tour and said screw it and invited him to my island since i liked him, until i realized that good god his house exterior was ugly and didn't fit my town at all. i didn't want to have more than one jock anyway so i let genji stay since i like him just as much but his house exterior fit my town and gave kid cat to a friend. ;_;

 

[Arithmophobia17]

it's not necessarily "regretting" but early on i chose to drop a normal in favor of four smugs, and i'm regretting that decision. like i really like colton, but i don't like him as much as i liked lolly when she was in my campsite, but at the time i was trying to open a plot for marshal... so in general, i'm definitely considering dropping colton, though it may end up coming down to reactions and diys that actually sends me over.

 

[ChrissyAndFrancineLover]

Rosie, twice. idk why i keep going back to her i don't really like her at all

OMG same! I have her Amiibo and i used it to kick Bubbles out,because i was villager hunting and saw Bubbles on an island,as soon as i saw her i left. I only had one NMT left,and found Piper. I thought her design was too basic,so i left her. I decided to just let a random villager move in. Believe it or not,it was BUBBLES! I was so mad,i used Rosie's Amiibo just to get rid of her. I actually really do not like Rosie,i liked her more in New Leaf. I want her to move out ASAP.

 

[Rabirin]

I finally got Marshal recently, and I thought i’d love him bc I had him in New Leaf but now that I have him he’s kinda just meh. Maybe i’ll fall in love with him a lil more eventually, but after having Julian for so long (he was my first campsite villager) I really grew to love Julian’s sass, but I let him go because I wanted Marshal so bad. But now that I have him, I kinda just think of Julian when I talk to him.

Same with Zucker and Sherb, I just didn’t feel like either suited the lazy personality. They didn’t really fit that “little kid” image for me, even though I wanted them to bc their designs are so cute.

 

[JKDOS]

Merry. Her smile creeped me out, so I had to give her away and find a new peppy

 

[river]

Julian. Twice. It's really a bummer because I still think that he's sooo beautiful, I love his house and he really fits my town. But I don't know why I can never form a real attachment to him. I had him in NL and gave him away and I'm considering doing it again in NH.
Maybe it has to do with a thing I've noticed happening to me, that I tend to value much more the villagers I have found on islands then the ones I bought through here... But who knows, I'm still giving Julian a third chance, maybe he'll grow on me

 

[shayminskyforme88]

Probably Merengue for this game. I decided to trade for her early on since I got her from a close friend here back in 2014 and she hasn’t logged back on for a really long time. So kinda decided I want to have her as a tribute to her on my island. But then, I found other Normals I decided to try as well on islands. Namely Maple, Marina, and Lily. They definitely grew on me more than Merengue. I was able to give Lily to someone who had her as their dreamy, but might let Merengue go once I see someone I like in the campsite. After all anyways, I still have the Merengue I got from my friend in my New Leaf town.

 

[Jun-Yo]

Zucker...i thought it was fate that i found him on a tarantula island and my as my final original 10 but then I found out my sister has him and then found out that he's a pretty common villager. He's cute and unique yes but those little things made him feel not too special for me and i like alot of Lazies like Punchy, Stitches and I want them thinking of replacing poor Zucker

 

[brockbrock]

Zucker...i thought it was fate that i found him on a tarantula island and my as my final original 10 but then I found out my sister has him and then found out that he's a pretty common villager. He's cute and unique yes but those little things made him feel not too special for me and i like alot of Lazies like Punchy, Stitches and I want them thinking of replacing poor Zucker

This was almost me. I was so close to inviting Zucker, but for whatever reason I don't like him nearly as much as I did in NL. I miss his old shirt... maybe that's a large part of it, because I thought it fit him much better.

 

[Globes216]

Audie. I found her on a mystery tour and was so so excited for her. When she came to my town her house automatically Clashed with the 'vibe' of my town. I also really didn't think her personality as peppy fit her all too well. And she was always working out, like for whatever reason whenever I saw her she was either in the town square or outside her ouse working out. It kind of bothered me a bit. I ended up letting her go to someone else who wanted her a lot more than I did

 

[senbeiiscool]

Merengue for me. I really wanted her and loved her design since NL days. But I never saw her do much on my island and was kinda boring, my best memory of her is her interacting with my vending machine so that's not saying much. I ended up moving her out but I'd like her back one day to give her another chance though. She's still very cute

 

[Fye]

Bruce. He's such a beautiful deer (/goat) and his house is pretty unique (its literally an alley haha) but talking to him just felt kind of off. I feel like if he was a smug or jock I would have kept him, but the cranky dialogue didn't suit his appearance, especially when compared to my other cranky - Wolfgang.

 

[Koala92]

Tia. I loved her, but she didn’t mesh with my island or me at all.

 

[YunaApple]

Maple. I saw her on a mystery island and invited her to my island with a quickness because she was the cutest little teddy graham cracker. The problem is that she's just kinda dull and just there. I connected much more to my other villagers, even Ed who I didn't like much at first.

 

[Wowzer Bowser]

I remember really wanting Molly but then I got her and she was my 6th normal and I just felt kind of meh at that point

 

[petrichr]

I always wanted Merengue and Marina in NL and I got them both in NH but the normal personality is so... meh. I'm really disappointed with it. I'll sell them both on soon I think.
I'm also experiencing smug fatigue hahah - I have Eugene and Lopez both saying the same dialogue and it's driving me nuts.

 

[brockbrock]

I have to add Merengue to this. I love her and had her in my New Leaf town, but she was too similar to Tia whom I was never going to part with. Even if I looked past their identical personalities, they are roughly the same size and both have design themes around food/tea, which was bugging me enough to let her move out when she asked.