Do you ever feel villager regret?

[Jellieyz]

DOM omg he was my starting villager and I really regretted letting him go.

He was my first ever friend, we didn't like Flo as much. He didn't give me a picture when he left and that made me sadder :c

I am hunting for him in my own pace though, he'll come back soon

 

[Sefyre]

Felt really bad about letting Gigi leave as she was one of my first villagers in City Folk too ;-; ironically, she moved into my mom's town! And she remembered me! My mom loves her so I feel a lil better about letting her go.

I've gotten rather attached to some of my partner's villagers and I would be very tempted to adopt them if they were to leave.

I'm so glad your mom loves her. This sounds like one of the happiest endings I could think of.

 

[Squinish]

Felt really bad about letting Gigi leave as she was one of my first villagers in City Folk too ;-; ironically, she moved into my mom's town! And she remembered me! My mom loves her so I feel a lil better about letting her go.

Well that was the best move ever. Sure it's sad to let them go, but you just gave your mom a great gift. Now she has a part of you in her town. Any time she wants to think of you. She can just see and talk to Gigi.

Post automatically merged: May 26, 2020

DOM omg he was my starting villager and I really regretted letting him go.

He was my first ever friend, we didn't like Flo as much. He didn't give me a picture when he left and that made me sadder :c

I am hunting for him in my own pace though, he'll come back soon

If I had his photo. I would give him to you. Dom is not part of my grand plans. I invited him to my island cause he has no Amiibo. So he is rarer to get. So figured, grab him now and get his photo. It could take anywhere from a few days to a few weeks. I mean Pashmina has been with me since day 1 and she has not given me a photo. Yet her BF, Sherb has given me his photo and he has only been with me half as long.

 

[Romaki]

I invited Audie into my island again and I already regret it. She's pretty, but I'm so annoyed by her fitness hobby.

 

[Fendi]

I wouldn't necessarily say I feel regret, however, when I did let Pango go, I did question myself a little afterwards if I made the right choice. She was such a sweet villager, and I miss seeing her walking around with her pink purse. But at the same time, I feel as if she did voluntarily ask to go, so I don't feel as bad since she had that idea.

I know it's all programmed, but let me dream!

 

[Envy]

It was painful to let Aurora go. It almost made me cry, but I needed a spot for Vivian. I haven't regretted it.

 

[jokk]

yes, all the time. i get bored with my villagers quickly but i still hate letting them go

 

[biksoka]

Let Poncho go because he had the starter house. I miss my jock ... he also never got to hang out with Kid Cat (who I let move in because he wanted a rival ;w; )and do their jock thing.

 

[DeltaLoraine]

I miss Skye sometimes. Whenever I ran into her, she was always singing. I missed seeing her around the island and listening to her songs...but I gave her to a good home, so she wasn't voided. It makes me happy knowing she's still out there singing on another island.

 

[Yujian]

I made the horrible mistake of letting Avery leave and I still regret it he was so cool!

 

[ohno dannie]

ive had this when inviting villagers? i find them nice and think id enjoy having them on the island, but then when they get there, i wish i had found someone else

 

[Pomme]

I definitely feel regret when I let a villager leave. But if I really want this villager to come back in future playing, I can : I have amiibos now, so it's just a goodbye see you later

 

[soomi]

Going to copy this from a thread I posted on another forum. To save me some time typing.
---------------------------

Ok, so yesterday I had a chance to get Raymond. I really wanted Raymond. Me and so many other, right? Well I had to loose a villager. I had a couple that I was ok with letting go of. I had their Framed Photos and took good care of them. They would have been missed but I was ok with there leaving.

Tangy was not meant to be one of them. I mean I had her Photo (she was the first to give me one). She is my second favorite villager. She makes the cutest face when you give her a gift and she is like, "Willy, I can haz." I gave her a green cheerleader uniform that she would wear all the time.

View attachment 265693

Try as I might. I could not get anyone else to leave and time was running out and.... and... I told her it was ok to leave. "You go be a super star. Follow your dreams Tangy. Your going to go far kid." I have had Tangy in every Animal Crossing game I have played and she has left me before, but this time. This is the first time I gave her permission to leave.

I said my goodbyes and got Raymond. He's great, I love him but today. I stopped in at the Service Center. Just checking for Rusted Parts cause Guliver was on the island the day before. As I am looking I saw an outfit. It was a Cheerleader Uniform. It was a green Cheerleader Uniform.

She forgot it as she was moving out and I am on the floor of the service center crying like a baby. Why did I do it? Just to get Sassy Cat. I mean sure, I really like him but WHY! Why couldn't Marina or Skye said they wanted to move? Why not Ankha? Sure Ankha is my favorite villager, but I have her amiibo so I can get her back easy. No, it had to be Tangy.

God my heart hurts right now. I am going to make a little memory shrine for Tangy until the day she comes back. On that day I will give her back her Cheerleader Uniform and beg her to never leave me again.


View attachment 265690

This hit me right in the feels. I hope you get her back

 

[Rosie977]

Not exactly letting a villager move out, but not letting one move in...
I was island hopping for Raymond when I found Bones, he was adorable so I took him. Later that day I found Sherb, who I REALLY wanted, but didn't take because I now had Bones. So I went back to my island sad that I couldn't take him, and I didn't like Bones because of that...
It would have been amazing to have Sherb, but now I'm happy to have left him. I still have Bones and don't regret it!

 

[Aliya]

I've had the opposite where I invite them and regret it lmao. Usually if a villager moves out, it's because I've wanted them to for a while.

Although letting starting villagers go is always a little tough for me. Even if I fully intended on not keeping them, they started the island with everyone and it's sad they don't get to stick around to see the island continue to grow and prosper.

 

[InstantNoodles]

Man I was sad when I let Sherb go but my favourite lazy villagers are Raddle and Bob (I can't deal with more than 2 lazies on the same island haha). Also, I was sad when I let Klaus go because of his cool Roman bathhouse theme, but once again I would have too many smugs if I kept him.

 

[cheezu]

Yupp... Has happened to me with Apple and Norma especially since I used amiibo cards to boot them out. They were the first two villagers to give me their photos as well. They were not my dreamies but have been with me since the start of the game.
I'm also still confused about some of the villagers I want to let go vs keep permanently.

 

[Globes216]

Kidd for me. He asked to leave and I had 3 goat villagers and I just thought it was his time. I have found him so often on mystery islands afterwards and it’s so hard to turn him down every time. If I ever have a second island I’d absolutely have him on it.

Another one was Canberra, she was my starter and one of my favourite villagers. She had her starter house so when she asked to leave I let her and I was so sad about it. About 3 weeks after I got the opportunity to adopt her again so I did and I am so happy to have my koala baby back

 

[Believe]

I think I'm kindave on the opposite spectrum on this. I tend to play so safe on my villager tastes that I never let them go for the sake of being sorta okay with them. I'm forcing myself to try new villagers this go around and I'm realizing my tastes are more versatile than I thought they were. Bringing in Biff, Peanut, and Dom were decisions made on a whim and it has really paid off

 

[Anblick]

My biggest problem is that I feel SO GUILTY kicking anybody out even if they are just not my cup of tea. I'm stuck with freaking Klaus, who has a really cute house and keeps giving me really nice DIYs and whatnot but he is so creepy looking augh... but I feel sooooo baddddd telling anybody to move out. Maybe I'll be able to work up to it someday ughhhhh.