I have Dotty, she's my favourite and I have a rather cute town. I don't find her red eyes creepy - at first I thought it was a bit odd, but it quickly faded; I just didn't know about it at first so it was surprising. At first I thought it was a graphic glitch, lol. Ruby is definitely better than Dotty for a creepy town, imo, since her permanent red eyes and her expression fit more. Dotty's just cute and cuddly most of the time and I find her black-and-white fur less creepy than Ruby's all-white one.