I can see what you mean, but personally, I find none of them creepy. Maybe Moe a little because of those eyes, but i think he’s so adorable and I love his color scheme ^.^. I used to not care for Kiki’s design; Idk if it was her nose or eyes, but now I especially love that squished nose and her eyes are so pretty.
Katt and Tabby I initially was one of the people that thought they were ugly and had no interest in them, but thanks to
@WaileaNoRei and others, I think they’re actually cute. They do have a unique design and appearance that i do see why they don’t appeal to many, but I think that’s part of what makes them interesting and unique.
Rudy: has the best expressions after Punchy (in my opinion). I initially was neutral about his rudolph appearance and thought I wouldn’t like him since the only other jock that i had (in NL) I didn’t like (the muscle talk bothered me, so now I realize it wasn’t the villager so much even though I couldn’t get him to move and that annoyed me).
Raymond: I love how he looks so grumpy; it makes his toothy grin melt my heart so much. I like some villagers with appearances that don’t match their personality. I don’t see him creepy at all but I can kinda understand why some people think he’s kinda boring looking even though I personally think he’s interesting.
Purrl: I am interested in her but I didn’t really have any interest in her until recently.
Olivia: I guess I can see why she may be creepy. I never was interested in her but I think she’s actually pretty now even though I like a lot of thr other cat’s designs better.
I don’t like Monique with the lipstick, but I don’t find her creepy.