Cookie or Maddie?

[helloxcutiee]

I like the look of Maddie a lot more.

 

[treetops]

I like Maddie! It's simple and more realistic, and I want to see that sort of stuff in more villagers.

I think cute villagers are nice and all, but Cookie is way too cute for my liking. I'm sorry, but I really don't like her design.

 

[Seashell]

Maddie?
Cookie's never been too appealing to me with those giant eyes.. I suppose she's alright, though. please, nobody, take no offense.;;
So.. Yeah. Maddie.

 

[MorningStar]

Jumping on the "Cookie has cute eyes" bandwagon.

 

[MayorBlueRose]

i have Maddie in my town and i just prefer her design to cookies.
Even though they are both cute!