Cookie or Apple?

[Hopeless Opus]

i love cookie!

 

[Elin1O]

Nooo, Apple all the way. She might look a little spooky yeah, but I don't like the design of Cookie at all. Her nose and eyes are huge, and I don't like the fact that she's a pink dog. I dunno, she's just not cute imo.
When my IRL friend took her in from the campsite, he said "aw look how cute she is!", while I awkwardly smiled, and said yeah... yeah she looks ok.
Hehe.

 

[Charcolor]

i like apple better. cookie's eyes kinda creep me out. they're like bug eyes.

 

[Cascade]

Cookie is much better

 

[Daydream]

Apple!

 

[robbywow]

When I first read the title I thought you meant "Would you rather eat a cookie or an apple"

 

[cornimer]

Cookie. I had her in my first town and really liked her. I've never been a fan of Apple.

 

[Buttonsy]

Thanks for all the responses! I think I've decided I want Apple, as nice as Cookie is.

Even though I've chosen a villager though, people can keep voting just for fun!!

 

[drowningfairies]

I have both in my town, and as much as I adore Cookie, I'll have to say Apple on this one since I love the hamsters.

 

[Rabirin]

I had Cookie in my town as a voided villager for a while, I liked her quite a bit. She was a dreamie beforehand, but eventually she was voided into my village so all hopes of that was gone haha. Personally I prefer her design much more over Apple's and I have a little bit distaste for the hamster villagers if i'm quite honest. They're kind of cute in some aspects, but not really imo. Besides, out of all the hamster villagers i've seen or had Apple is my least favourite so far. She has an adorable catchphrase but something the area around her mouth seems off - and as if nintendo were trying too hard to make her appear cuter. I prefer Cookie imo because of her sparkly eyes, her colour palette and her villager model. But whichever you go for is up to you.