Cookie or Apple?

[Buttonsy]

I'm trying to pick a peppy to replace Anabelle when she moves out, but I can't decide! I thought I'd ask for opinions.

 

[That Marshal Fangirl]

Cookie is so cute!!! Apple creeps me out a bit to be honest.

 

[ChillyKio]

Cookie. I can't place why I dislike Apple. I think it's the eyes... though, she is a hamster, and hamsters are small and cute.
I prefer Cookie!

 

[Mothership]

This is a tough choice, but I like Apple a bit more than Cookie.

 

[sylviabee]

Cookie because I prefer the dogs!

 

[Aleigh]

Def my bby Cookie. She's such an amazing villager! One of my favorites.

 

[Kurashiki]

i'd go with cookie! not a big fan of apple

 

[PrincessPixiTheThird]

Cookie! Apple kinda... creeps me out. Idk. I think I see a hint of bloodlust in those eyes...

 

[Idfldnsndt]

I love them both and I've had them both and I'm going to say Apple because Cookie looks a bit too... out there for me

 

[ZebraQueen]

Apple I just love her
Plus cookie it's weird and not nicely (she was a stare)

 

[rocklazy]

I dislike both of their designs but I'd pick Cookie cause she looks like she wouldn't go on a killing spree in town while Apple could

 

[charyse]

i'd pick cookie i had her in my town in the original animal crossing she's a doll

 

[Aerchan]

Cookie! I want her but at the same time I want so many others I can never decide!

 

[Nunnafinga]

Nothing against Apple but yeah....Cookie.

 

[Corrie]

I like both!! I'd go with Cookie, though. Apple's stare can be scary. XD

 

[LinkToTheWorld]

I really do find Apple a bit creepy. There is a picture floating around the internet somewhere of her with that crazy look on her face and holding an axe in one hand....don't think I'd enjoy seeing her in my town after that unfortunately
I've had Cookie in my town before, she's very cute, although a little pink for me. Her eyes are adorable. Peppy is a difficult one for me because I find it grates on me after a while but Cookie is definitely one of my favourites

 

[Nunbal]

Cookie is cute but Apple for me.

I never found Apple to be creepy. I think she fits the peppy personality to a T.

 

[namiieco]

I don't like either but Cookie is better for me

 

[ashlif]

Cookie is cuter than Apple

 

[VanillaChase]

I love both Cookie and Apple, but I think I like Cookie just a little better.