Chadder or Colton?

[treetops]

[removed]

 

[Skylanx]

Colton. He looks charming and more good looking than chadder. And since he fits in more in your town, you should definitely get him instead of chadder.

 

[saarahsuper]

This may be a little biased, but my vote goes to Chaddar. He may not necessarily go with the colour palette theme of your dreamies but that doesn't mean you shouldn't get him. The little tux he wears and his smug look on his face screams to me classy gentleman and that's how I feel a smug villiager should be. Though that doesn't mean I don't feel the same way about Colton - he's a great guy too but I feel Chadder fits more into the role. I'm sure this isn't very helpful at all and is instead just an acnl fan rambling on so I'm gonna stop! My vote goes to Chadder but I just wanna say whichever one you pick will be a great addition to your town and kudos to you for picking an underrated smug villager as I feel they are strongly underappreciated. Chadder, Shep, Ken, O'hare, Keaton and especially Jacques are definitely some of my favourites! <3

 

[Belle of Pripyat]

I think Chadder is adorable and Colton is hideous.

 

[galaxysparks]

As much as I love Chadder, I'm gonna have to say Colton. If he fits better in your town, then he's the better choice.

 

[FancyThat]

I had to go with Chadder as I think he's design is adorable.

 

[wolfie1]

I think Chadder, as well as Colton, is horrible, but Colton looks better.

 

[AccfSally]

Chadder, he's a total sweetheart.

 

[meowduck]

I like both honestly. I had Colton in my town and my brother has Chadder in his right now they're both super sweet

 

[Seren]

Colton is the worst and put his house in the worst spot but I have to admit his fabulousness is pretty amusing.

 

[Soda Fox]

While I really like horse villagers, Colton is my least favorite of all of them. I chose Chadder because I think he's cuter.

 

[cornimer]

I like Colton, I had him in my town and he's very sweet! His house is very nice as well.

Oh no, I tied it. Whoops. XD

 

[Vickie]

♥ i would say colton,
he gives me a prince charming kind of vibe,
and i would totally love him to be in my town but i already got marshal c: ♥
~♚Vickie​

 

[Candyapple]

Chadder! He was in my campsite one time but I had no space in town. He is so small and funny, plus a mouse made out of cheese, how cool is that? I love cheese, I love Chadder!

 

[Snowfell]

I voted for Colton. For whatever reason his design has always kind of reminded me of Tamaki from Ouran Host Club. It's a silly reason I know, but I like Colton for that.

 

[HungryForCereal]

go for chadder! he's actually pretty cute tbh. i actually hate mice in acnl but hes an exception. might get him if i get a chance to.

 

[Greggy]

Chadder. I don't know much about Colton besides from visits at random Dream Addresses, but from what I saw in him he's a bit so-so, though he's the best smug horse imo. I have Chadder and he's the best smug I have so far, and he's such a romantic lil' cheese mouse. When it comes to houses, I also prefer Chadder's because there's so many snooty villagers with houses similar to Colton's.

 

[Rabirin]

I think if you like Chadder's character design a little better then Colton, then chances are you will like him better then Colton. Although both are pretty good choices I think Chadder's pretty unique, and would just give your town that boost of unique about it. Not to mention he's a mouse, so he'd look adorable when standing in flowers and such.

 

[ZetaFunction]

Although I've never had either of them in any of my towns, I'd probably go with Chadder. He just seems more fun and looks like he has a nice personality that might fit pretty well in your town, although Colton would fit pretty well too. But Chadder is definitely my favorite since food villagers are the best

 

[radioloves]

Both seems like a good choice, but I'm leaning more towards Colton because he seems to fit well with many town themes, and has a great personality trait for his character c: