Biff or Mac?

[xSuperMario64x]

De nada. I honestly don't get why people like him and basically all hippos used to infest my towns in NL x_x

RIGHT. I had Hippeux move into my NL town once and I gagged every time I saw him lmaoooo

 

[fluttershy300]

Only hippo I like is Bertha.

 

[Alienfish]

RIGHT. I had Hippeux move into my NL town once and I gagged every time I saw him lmaoooo

I had him, Bubbles and that beard one stalking me so much like.. ugh why lol.

 

[Luxen]

Biff's design looks more appealing to me, so I'm going with him.
Mac's design just looks odd to me. If villagers could also have unique head/ear shapes like special NPCs (or at least 1-3 variants), I'd probably pick him instead.

 

[futuristicsalad]

Aww man that's a tough one because they both have sentimental value to me! Mac was my starting villager in NH and I found him absolutely enjoyable to have on my island, and due to a misclick in the game, I let him go too early when he asked me about him leaving... And Biff was my best buddy all the way back in GC, so I was excited to see him make a come back for Welcome Amiibo after not being active for so long. Honestly, I love them both equally and I don't like one over the other. If I had to choose though, I'll give it to Biff just because hippos are painfully underrated and deserve more love.