I find it interesting how players can have such a different opinion of the same character. It's cool. Every villager gets love.
Your list is actually composed of the villagers I hate the most, except for Goldie. And your profile pic is the villager I hate more than any other. I've been trying to get him to move out since I started this town. But I'm glad you like him
Oh wow. It's a close match between Goldie and Beau since I have both in my town and I love them. Goldie is a cute lil dog that is always nice to you and the dog villagers are just really cute. Goldie also reminds me of my childhood dog and that's why I have that small connection with her. You can't go wrong with them. Beau, on the other hand, is a bit more elegant since he's a deer but still has a lot of cute aspects and looks good in pink (he's wearing a pink smock with a red backpack in my town) plus he's the first deer villager that I got and that holds a special spot. Either Goldie or Beau are amazing and you should keep them
P.S. Cyrano is a cute cranky. I love him in the animal crossing movie tbh