I chose wolfgang. I had him in my town for awhile. He was pretty cool. I was going for an all hamster ( with two mice ) town, so I gave him to a friend.
Fang! So pretty and I love wintery looking animals. He was my buddy for a while but I'm slowly letting my town get taken over by cats so he had to go eventually XD
He's a resident in my town, he's very sweet for a Cranky villager, he has a nice design, and his name reminds me of a composer. His current catchphrase is "Mozart", as a matter of fact. XD
I think Wolfgang is the only one of the four I've been in a town with. In my old town, he was one of my starters, one of my besties, and usually was the one with the nicest, smartest, and funniest things to say.
And he kept that miyama stag for the whole year, right up until the day I reset.