I'm really bad at letting villagers go, I get rather attached whether they are dreamies or not. However, when my starters do ask me to leave, I'm afraid I am going to be wishing them the best of luck. I recently did some research and figured out who my dreamies are and who aren't. Neither of my starters were one of my 38 dreamies. That being said, I'm not going to be rushing them out via time travelling either. When they are ready to leave, they can go. (that, or once I start scanning amiibo for my campsite)
Are you keeping your starter villagers?
- Thread starter Moon Cake
- Start date
pale-tiger
Everything's peachy
Buck and Pashmina are my starter villagers and I would definitely like both of them to stay. Buck is my 'best friend' on the island so I really wouldn't want him to leave. It's annoying that they'll never get their normal interiors in their houses, but maybe (hopefully) a future update/patch could change how that works. The next three were/are Marcie, Anicotti and Hugh. I like them all but I think I'd say yes if any of them asked to move.
peachmilke
sproutling
I kept deirdre, but I reset for her... so yeah, not gonna put 3 hours to waste lol
VanitasFan26
I'm just a ghost.
I just started a 2nd island and the villagers I got were Syliva and Mac. So I am going to say no and just kick them out by the time I get the campsite since I have amiibo cards.
Foreverfox
✨💖glow & shine💖✨
I had Charlise and Antonio as my starters. I hated Charlise and kicked her out as soon as I could, but im keeping Antonio - he is the best! He's not going anywhere lol.
VanitasFan26
I'm just a ghost.
Haha I remember having Antonio as one of my starter villagers from my 1st island back in 2020 and the other one was Rocket.
Dunquixote
No dms and discord messages
I kept Rudy, though I needed to amiibo him out two times since I messed up his house’s interior. I considered keeping Lily but I didn’t care for the starter house for her, there was a bug i couldn’t get her to get rid of and there were other villagers I wanted.
I initially planned on letting Rudy go since I did not expect I’d like him, but now, he is never leaving unless I mess up his house again.
I’ll invite him back if that does happen.
I initially planned on letting Rudy go since I did not expect I’d like him, but now, he is never leaving unless I mess up his house again.
I’ll invite him back if that does happen.
Bluebellie
Senior Member
I have kept zero of my starter villagers. I picked all of my villagers from amiibos, I don’t really like the game picking it for me.
DarkSlayer1331
Senior Member
Oh man. I don't still have my starter villagers, but I actually wound up loving both of them. Katt and Coach. Unfortunately, I let Katt go too soon. She left my island in May, and I thought that I would be okay with that, but I wound up missing her terribly, and I wish that I had at least kept her through Halloween. Coach was around for a much longer time, though. If I remember correctly, he didn't leave until November, or maybe even December. I'm positive I had him for Halloween, but I'm not sure if he was around for Turkey Day... I know he was gone by Toy Day for sure. Both of them are now a couple of my favorite villagers, and I do hope to have them again someday. So I'm a little sad to see that your campsite nor random move-ins will ever be a villager you've had living on your island before, unless you've had every single villager of that personality live on your island at some point. It'll be a long time to have them again, unless I get their amiibo or happen to find them during a villager hunt via mystery islands.
mermaidshelf
Senior Member
Even though I got one of my dreamies as a starter, I ended up moving her out and moving her back in with an Amiibo because I wanted her to have the personalized interior rather than the generic one they give the starter uchis.
he was one of my dreamies and I think the cozy cabin interior suits him soooo well
I thought everybody got a Jock and an Uchi as starter villagers?
Post automatically merged:
Both of mine are long gone. I got Billy and Fuschia. Billy was okay but Jocks drive me nuts and Fuschia caused so many arguments on the island that she had to go! She really put me off Uchi villagers until I took a chance on Agnes who has become one of my absolute favourites ❤
A year later, I still have Louie and Agnes. They are amazing, and I will never let them leave. NEVER.
Post automatically merged:
Oh my gosh, Agnes was my starter. I love her!
Disneyfangirl23
Senior Member
Nah they don’t really go with my island~
I had Hamlet and Flo as my starter villagers but I swapped them both out when they each got the thought bubble. While I had them though I thought they were both quite nice, especially Hamlet who I liked a lot more than I thought I would, but there are too many villagers that I prefer so they couldn't stay.
moonlights
Senior Member
Mine were Frita and Tank. I like both and they're actually still on my island but I would like to replace them eventually and meet some new jock and sisterly villagers.
Similar threads
