Anything You've Regretted Gifting to A Villager?

i gave the million bell crown to dom, im very happy i gave it to him tho
Edit: NO REGRETS!!!!
 
Idk if that's for sure how it works, I just know so many of my villagers frequently wear the first thing I gave them. Maybe I've just been somehow nailing their style preferences every time without knowing? Definitely not matched on color though lol.

And I do have one exception - Lionel used to wear the blue denim dress I first gave him a lot, but now he's more into a white/gray jumper thing. But then again, maybe the first thing I gave him wasn't that dress, it was the Dodo Airlines sleeping mask thing. And yes, he does frequently walk around blind with that thing on, LOL
Yeah maybe they just love the stuff you gave them haha. OMG I've given a sleeping mask to Kitt before and it sat on her nose of all things ;___; Sometimes items work a lot more differently than I expect them to 😔
Post automatically merged:

Eyepatch to Lucky. I thought it would go on the other eye. He loves wearing it but I wish he wouldn't.
Oh no Lucky... how does he even see now?? ;__;
Post automatically merged:

i gave the million bell crown to dom, im very happy i gave it to him tho
Edit: NO REGRETS!!!!
I've given a crown too... even though it's left on the floor... 😭 NO REGRETS!!!
Post automatically merged:

ugh yes.. i gave agnes glasses and they look so bad on her
I'm terrified of giving glasses to villagers besides ones that already wear them, I've given enough terrible gifts already though I should probably just visit Harv more often to try things out 😩
 
i gave bunnie a red dress thinking it would look cute, but it clashes with her colour palette. i’ve given her so many other outfits but she wears that dress most days 😭 i don’t even remember the last time i seen her in her original clothes
 
Giving Rex a bunny day dress... always gotta report him to Isabelle e__e
 
I gave Lionel a jockey uniform - the pink one with stars. I wanted to get a gift back and it was the only thing in my inventory I could gift... I remember thinking "pfft, villagers don't wear pants, so he won't wear it." He does. Pantless. All the time.

I also regret every fish and bug request I've completed. Not worth it.

We should be able to peek in villager closets and steal back gifts.
 
I gifted Maple a baseball uniform early on. She questioned my choice but then unfortunately started wearing the green baseball uniform every day. I got rid of her to make room for another villager mostly, but that uniform clashed so bad with everything that is Maple.
 
I accidentally gave Zucker a small silk hat and he wore it for a day, then put it in his house and it duplicated. So now he has two. :|

I also gave Marina a pink soft serve hat and it was absolutely hilarious. She only wore it once though and now it's just been sitting in her house. I also gave Whitney some sunglasses that I thought would look good on her but they don't. Will have to replace those eventually.
 
Tammy is now walking around in a jester cap every now and then like booboo the fool. Knox is wearing little strawberry pajamas from time to time. The only reason this happened is because I accidentally hit "This is for you" on both of them and didn't want to be rude by not giving something so I (thinking you could reset clothing with isabelle WRONGO) gave them whatever was in my invo, usually gifts from other animals.
Post automatically merged:

I also gave diana a green little barette thing and green is not her color. Could be worse though lol
Post automatically merged:

I wish flora would wear her eggshell hat
 
Hearing all the sea bass and flea horror stories make me glad I have a habit of always releasing those right after I catch them.
 
i gave bunnie a red dress thinking it would look cute, but it clashes with her colour palette. i’ve given her so many other outfits but she wears that dress most days 😭 i don’t even remember the last time i seen her in her original clothes
Oh no D; Maybe just gift her a ton of clothing so it goes away from her rotation?? (or talk to isabelle?)
Post automatically merged:

Giving Rex a bunny day dress... always gotta report him to Isabelle e__e
OH NOOOO bunny day stuff is really... colourful... and doesn't look great on villagers ;__;
Post automatically merged:

I gave Lionel a jockey uniform - the pink one with stars. I wanted to get a gift back and it was the only thing in my inventory I could gift... I remember thinking "pfft, villagers don't wear pants, so he won't wear it." He does. Pantless. All the time.

I also regret every fish and bug request I've completed. Not worth it.

We should be able to peek in villager closets and steal back gifts.
Wow I wonder which villager would actually look good in that jockey uniform.... I've never actually tried gifting pants before haha
I really wish I could steal some stuff back too, sometimes things just look TERRIBLE on my villagers
Post automatically merged:

I gifted Maple a baseball uniform early on. She questioned my choice but then unfortunately started wearing the green baseball uniform every day. I got rid of her to make room for another villager mostly, but that uniform clashed so bad with everything that is Maple.
Raymond bought a red baseball uniform off me... it looks SO BAD on him. I just kept gifting him other sportswear and thankfully he doesn't really wear it anymore. But man when he does, I spot it instantly cause it clashes so much. 😩
Post automatically merged:

I gave Hamphrey that wedding ring item by mistake. Worst thing about it is he didn't even display it in his house.
Oof. Lol maybe he likes it a lot!! 😂
Post automatically merged:

I accidentally gave Zucker a small silk hat and he wore it for a day, then put it in his house and it duplicated. So now he has two. :|

I also gave Marina a pink soft serve hat and it was absolutely hilarious. She only wore it once though and now it's just been sitting in her house. I also gave Whitney some sunglasses that I thought would look good on her but they don't. Will have to replace those eventually.
Yeah Whitney has duplicated items too :( It's nothing major, but I hope nintendo can patch it soon, cause it looks kinda silly
Post automatically merged:

Tammy is now walking around in a jester cap every now and then like booboo the fool. Knox is wearing little strawberry pajamas from time to time. The only reason this happened is because I accidentally hit "This is for you" on both of them and didn't want to be rude by not giving something so I (thinking you could reset clothing with isabelle WRONGO) gave them whatever was in my invo, usually gifts from other animals.
Post automatically merged:

I also gave diana a green little barette thing and green is not her color. Could be worse though lol
Post automatically merged:

I wish flora would wear her eggshell hat
LMAO gifting pajamas to villagers is pretty funny when they walk outside in them :LOL: Yeah when I accidentally press "this is for you" I pray there's no bugs or fish in my pockets ;__; Looooll Flora wearing an eggshell hat sounds adorable!
 
Last edited:
During the 'Bunny Day' event week, I was in the holiday spirit (plus I has more eggs than I could count). Me, being a good neighbor (and an idiot), I gave each villager an egg costume. By the end of the 'Bunny Day' event I was sick of seeing all this EGG STUFF! I didn't want to see another egg item again.

Alas, it never stops, and I'm reminded of 'Bunny day' every time one of my villagers wears the gift I gave them!

BRUH!:

thumbnail.jpg
thumbnail.jpg
thumbnail.jpg
 
Hearing all the sea bass and flea horror stories make me glad I have a habit of always releasing those right after I catch them.
Yeah, fruit is definitely the way to go if you don't want to ruin homes 😔 I sigh whenever I see the fish or bugs displayed in my villager's homes... maybe eventually I can gift them enough stuff so they'll put it away
Post automatically merged:

During the 'Bunny Day' event week, I was in the holiday spirit (plus I has more eggs than I could count). Me, being a good neighbor (and an idiot), I gave each villager an egg costume. By the end of the 'Bunny Day' event I was sick of seeing all this EGG STUFF! I didn't want to see another egg item again.

Alas, it never stops, and I'm reminded of 'Bunny day' every time one of my villagers wears the gift I gave them!

BRUH!:

View attachment 256354 View attachment 256355 View attachment 256356
Awww they look so cute in them!! Though yeah bunny day really lasted way too long and having to be reminded of that horror.... ouch 😭
 
Gave marina the tan coloured top coat by accident. Honestly, after going to Harv's island and trying some stuff on her, her design doesnt make a lot of shirts or dresses look good. She wore the shirt i gave her all the time and it was so ugly....... Eventually I voided her and bought her back because it annoyed me that much!
 
Gave marina the tan coloured top coat by accident. Honestly, after going to Harv's island and trying some stuff on her, her design doesnt make a lot of shirts or dresses look good. She wore the shirt i gave her all the time and it was so ugly....... Eventually I voided her and bought her back because it annoyed me that much!
Wow it was that bad?! :O I haven't had any octo villagers but yeah I can imagine gifting stuff to them might be a bit difficult 😥
 
During the 'Bunny Day' event week, I was in the holiday spirit (plus I has more eggs than I could count). Me, being a good neighbor (and an idiot), I gave each villager an egg costume. By the end of the 'Bunny Day' event I was sick of seeing all this EGG STUFF! I didn't want to see another egg item again.

Alas, it never stops, and I'm reminded of 'Bunny day' every time one of my villagers wears the gift I gave them!

BRUH!:

View attachment 256354 View attachment 256355 View attachment 256356
At least they're wearing the nicer colored ones. I gave Rex the ugly leaf one :(
 
I gave Fuchsia a pink boa parka. The lighter shade of pink didn't look as cute on her as I was hoping! Thankfully, she doesnt wear it much, but I believe she is displaying it in her house.
 
Back
Top