Anything You've Regretted Gifting to A Villager?
- Thread starter kojuuro
- Start date
When your Villager asks to buy a Flea from you and you don't think they'll put it in their interior so you say sure.
...Pinky, no, please, I love you but why are you displaying a flea in your house. I'm glad you love it so much but no baby.
...Pinky, no, please, I love you but why are you displaying a flea in your house. I'm glad you love it so much but no baby.
First I gifted Groucho a Tight Punk Outfit and a Safe for his House, which both worked quite well. Then I gave him a Student Cap, but instead of wearing it, he just replaced his Iron Hanger Stand with it. I was like: „Here. Take this Plant and go replace your hat immediately!“ And guess what? He replaced his Safe ...
At least Jacques put his Beret in his Fridge now, even if the Fridge is in front of his Window for some unknown reason. He even wears the Beret, but Groucho didn’t touched his Hat since the day I gifted it to him. Weird.
At least Jacques put his Beret in his Fridge now, even if the Fridge is in front of his Window for some unknown reason. He even wears the Beret, but Groucho didn’t touched his Hat since the day I gifted it to him. Weird.
MatchaMoonlight
We All Scream
I gave Poncho an outdoor table a while ago, but I forgot he already had a wooden table in his house. Now he has both tables on display in his house, and it looks really crowded. XD
I gave Julian a bamboo doll because the Kaguyahime myth it relates to seeeeemed like it'd be a good fit, but oop no it actually looks bad thematic or not
Also he did the thing where he puts out 2 of a gift, so he has 2 white music stands when I gave him 1, and he's replaced his Libra scales with the magic kit I gave him...sigh
Also he did the thing where he puts out 2 of a gift, so he has 2 white music stands when I gave him 1, and he's replaced his Libra scales with the magic kit I gave him...sigh
CookieBunny
Lucky bun
I gave Julian the blue Labelle sunglasses. He only wore them once before putting them in his room
Ohh noooo ;__; Cherry.... I'm sure she'll really cherish itKind of.
One time, my villager Cherry had fleas. I caught them for her. She goes "Wow thank you so much!". I spoke to her immediately again to see what else she had to say, and then she goes "Oh my god is that a flea on you?! Ooooh my god can I please have it please please pleaaase I'll give you 422 bells for it"
....
Suuuure Cherry
Post automatically merged:
Oh man she looks nude? I guess it's a lesson learned to give her a different colouri gave my diva a purple bathroom bc i thought it would be funny but now she walks around with it outside all the time
Maybe you can give her a ton of stuff to make her wear the other clothes more often
Post automatically merged:
I gave Ankha the regular tiny crown and she immediately left it on the floor after wearing it once
Post automatically merged:
Some of the clothing looks so weird stretched out on larger villagers... Every time I dress up Apollo I give him something simple now cause otherwise sometimes it looks strange. It must be so much harder for the girls since their clothes are usually a lot more detailedI gave Megan a princess dress and it stretched weird T_T. But it isn't as bad as when I gave Rocket a lace up dress.. I really hate how the clothing stretches
Post automatically merged:
Aww man, if it makes you feel any better, I had no idea it was a Gulliver item either and gave it away in one of my earliest trades to someone who just wanted to catalog it
Post automatically merged:
Omg literally me with Raymond. He bought an ugly red baseball uniform off me and refuses to take it off. I see it every day when he works out and AAHHH I wish he bought something else off me. I'm gifting him as many sporty outfits as possible now
Post automatically merged:
Wow that's honestly surprising, I thought she'd look pretty good in it considering... it sorta looks like it'd fit her? :O
Last edited:
Noel_in_Sunrise
Senior Member
I gave Puddles (a pink frog) a nurse's hat before I realized villagers wear hats now and she still wears it sometimes.
Ohh no, maybe the colour blended in with his ears? Going to Harv's island is a smart idea... I need to do it more often!
PuppyCat472
Member
Eyepatch to Lucky. I thought it would go on the other eye. He loves wearing it but I wish he wouldn't.
Once you give them a ton of clothes I hate how it just ends up showing up in their homes ;__;
Post automatically merged:
Fleas are the one hard line I say no to, my other villagers have beetles and sea bass in their homes though and it looks soooo badWhen your Villager asks to buy a Flea from you and you don't think they'll put it in their interior so you say sure.
...Pinky, no, please, I love you but why are you displaying a flea in your house. I'm glad you love it so much but no baby.
Post automatically merged:
Yeah I find villagers tend to leave hats and accessories alone, which sucks cause I love giving hats and other things to them too besides clothing
It's too bad they replace such cool furniture though... maybe they like our gifts a lot? (not enough to wear it though... 
)
Post automatically merged:
Omg I gave duplicate furniture too
I wanted to give a proper bed to Katt who was my original uchi, and she kept her stupid sleeping bag and her place ended up being tiny. When I gave her other things she just wouldn't get rid of the stuff from the beginning.
Post automatically merged:
Ohh man, Julian's house is so pretty... I'm sure it's hard to give him furniture that fits. My sister has Julian and gave him a blue clothes closet with a star pattern on it and hates it in his house
My Whitney totally duped the hair accessory I gave her too! It's really weird seeing 2 of the same thing in their homes...
Post automatically merged:
Wow nice quick thinking! Yeah sometimes hats look kinda weird on cats cause they get all squished and their ears are in the way...
Post automatically merged:
Idk if my villagers don't like Labelle items or what. I gave both Ankha and Whitney Labelle coats and they never wore them again before just leaving it in their rooms ;__;I gave Julian the blue Labelle sunglasses. He only wore them once before putting them in his room
Post automatically merged:
Yeah hats are sometimes hit or miss ;__; sometimes they wear them all the time, others... just left on the floor
Last edited:
Le Ham
now please I will accept the money-payment
Of note: I have not used Photopia yet. I should start using it to make sure they look good in what I give them haha.
I gifted Monty a groovy tunic. Specifically the worst color combination it has - hot pink/neon green I think? It seems like your villagers will quite often LOVE the first shirt you ever give them regardless of whether it fits their style, because that's been the case for Monty, Billy, Clay, Spike... I hate that he wears it, but I hardly ever go clothes shopping specifically for my villagers so I guess I need to shove a bunch more clothing at him before he'll stop wearing it since complaining doesn't make the shirt go away?
I gifted Clay a red tux. Yeah, red looks terrible on him. Bad move. Oh I also gave him a pair of overalls once and they wear like a dress on him and it's... undesirable.
Oh, um, I also learned that even if you tell a villager the outfit their fellow villager had you deliver to them looks terrible, they will continue to wear it anyway. Monty sent Spike a "stellar jumpsuit" that looks straight out of the 70s and I told him it looked bad, but he adores it. Guess they can both enjoy their midlife crises together, how sweet.
Earlier on some other villager sent Sprinkle a red baby romper and I hate it, but she loves it sooo
I gifted Monty a groovy tunic. Specifically the worst color combination it has - hot pink/neon green I think? It seems like your villagers will quite often LOVE the first shirt you ever give them regardless of whether it fits their style, because that's been the case for Monty, Billy, Clay, Spike... I hate that he wears it, but I hardly ever go clothes shopping specifically for my villagers so I guess I need to shove a bunch more clothing at him before he'll stop wearing it since complaining doesn't make the shirt go away?
I gifted Clay a red tux. Yeah, red looks terrible on him. Bad move. Oh I also gave him a pair of overalls once and they wear like a dress on him and it's... undesirable.
Oh, um, I also learned that even if you tell a villager the outfit their fellow villager had you deliver to them looks terrible, they will continue to wear it anyway. Monty sent Spike a "stellar jumpsuit" that looks straight out of the 70s and I told him it looked bad, but he adores it. Guess they can both enjoy their midlife crises together, how sweet.
Earlier on some other villager sent Sprinkle a red baby romper and I hate it, but she loves it sooo
LilBabyDelirium
Fairy Godmother/Partially Obscured Floaty Thing
Accidentally gave Flo the chess set I had JUST purchased for 99k. Ouch. Very ouch
Ohh I had no idea they like the first thing you give them! :O Oof some colours look bad on villagers and I've learned the hard way tooOf note: I have not used Photopia yet. I should start using it to make sure they look good in what I give them haha.
I gifted Monty a groovy tunic. Specifically the worst color combination it has - hot pink/neon green I think? It seems like your villagers will quite often LOVE the first shirt you ever give them regardless of whether it fits their style, because that's been the case for Monty, Billy, Clay, Spike... I hate that he wears it, but I hardly ever go clothes shopping specifically for my villagers so I guess I need to shove a bunch more clothing at him before he'll stop wearing it since complaining doesn't make the shirt go away?
I gifted Clay a red tux. Yeah, red looks terrible on him. Bad move. Oh I also gave him a pair of overalls once and they wear like a dress on him and it's... undesirable.
Oh, um, I also learned that even if you tell a villager the outfit their fellow villager had you deliver to them looks terrible, they will continue to wear it anyway. Monty sent Spike a "stellar jumpsuit" that looks straight out of the 70s and I told him it looked bad, but he adores it. Guess they can both enjoy their midlife crises together, how sweet.
Earlier on some other villager sent Sprinkle a red baby romper and I hate it, but she loves it sooo
Now I've opted to give the same colour clothing that they wear originally sometimes but it looks so bland. Yeah, I don't know the point of telling a villager if something looks bad if they wear it anyways, I told my villagers the same thing and they still keep it in their rotations, but I guess if they love it, I'll learn to love it too
Post automatically merged:
Ouch that is so sad ;___; At least you can still order it from your catalog but still... after you just got it too... I'd feel so sad
Diana asked me to buy a seabass that was in my pocket. Didn't think anything of it and I wanted to raise friendship so i agreed. She frikkin displayed that thing on her fireplace for weeks. Destroyed her decor for a while with a C+ Monstrosity. We coo now tho 
C+ monstrosity has literally destroyed 2 of my villager's homes ;__; RIP Marshal and Wolfgang I'm so sorryDiana asked me to buy a seabass that was in my pocket. Didn't think anything of it and I wanted to raise friendship so i agreed. She frikkin displayed that thing on her fireplace for weeks. Destroyed her decor for a while with a C+ Monstrosity. We coo now tho
Le Ham
now please I will accept the money-payment
Idk if that's for sure how it works, I just know so many of my villagers frequently wear the first thing I gave them. Maybe I've just been somehow nailing their style preferences every time without knowing? Definitely not matched on color though lol.Ohh I had no idea they like the first thing you give them! :O Oof some colours look bad on villagers and I've learned the hard way too
Yeah, I don't know the point of telling a villager if something looks bad if they wear it anyways, I told my villagers the same thing and they still keep it in their rotations, but I guess if they love it, I'll learn to love it too
And I do have one exception - Lionel used to wear the blue denim dress I first gave him a lot, but now he's more into a white/gray jumper thing. But then again, maybe the first thing I gave him wasn't that dress, it was the Dodo Airlines sleeping mask thing. And yes, he does frequently walk around blind with that thing on, LOL
Similar threads
