anyone else disagree with a villager's personality?

[BigBadButterfree]

I have Billy on my island and he's looks so old it's weird for him to be a jock. But I also like that about him, almost like he's one of those older guys that turned their life around and got for and healthy.

I also agree with the likes of Jambette and Diva. It's probably just the lipstick that makes me think that.

Oh, and someone on page 1 mentioned Lucha. I was mad when I saw him in my campsite cuz I thought he was jock. Then found out smug and it was so confusing. But thinking more about it, it kinda makes sense. The smug personality loves to talk about acting and so it just seems like Lucha is acting the part. Didn't stop me getting rid of him tho.

 

[Figment]

It bothered me hearing Lionel's smug voice, which sounds much younger than his design. It was really weird when he would flirt with my character.

Cranky wouldn't fit either, but I would have thought of Lionel as an old distinguished gentleman, like a grandfatherly character.

 

[thisisausername]

i thought Reneigh and Audie would be snooties but turns out Reneigh is uchi and Audie is peppy lol

i also thought Cyd would be smug or jock but... he's cranky????

 

[Clock]

Long time ago, I thought Ken was a cranky villager seeing him for the first time because of his color and appearance, but I realized he is a smug when I talked to him and he had the smug voice.

 

[VelveteenCat]

When I found out that Shep would be moving into an empty plot, I was kind of looking forward to having a cranky doggie around. No clue why, but I was totally convinced that he was a cranky. When he arrived, I found out that he's actually a smug and I just don't get it ... He seems so "rustic", even his interior is as down to earth as it gets.

 

[carackobama]

Audie should’ve been snooty, Judy should’ve been peppy and Dom should’ve been lazy imo! also I thought O’Hare was lazy for YEARS him being cranky is so weird to me

 

[Loriii]

Audie should have been the first female jock lol but yeah, she's pretty loud and cheerful so the peppy personality fits her. Judy should have been peppy instead so I could bring her back (don't want to have 3 snooty villagers in my island)

 

[Mayor Miraland]

Piper looks like she should be snooty but she's peppy-
I can't even complain about it tbh, I love that I can have a peppy villager in my town without breaking the fancy aesthetic :3

 

[metswee]

For me its raymond
I recently got him thru the camspsite for my partner and I thought itd be fun to get to know him while my partner got a plot open......Ive found I cannot stand him as a smug he talks about fashion and acting yet he looks like a little business man?? Think I would've loved him if he was cranky

 

[s i r e n t i c]

I was convinced Lucha was a jock until this post, that’s why I moved him out in the first place- I didn’t need two jocks.
Dom is another villager that doesn’t really fit, when I first saw him I was convinced he would be a lazy villager.
Rudy is another villager that I thought would be something other then a jock, just based on appearances and stuff.

 

[ForbiddenSecrets]

Honestly I never have. I've been surprised before (like with Dom) because of how same-y they make the personalities look overall but I've never disagreed. I like that some don't fit the exact 'type' mold.

 

[Kyneria]

Rooney looks like, and has a jock styled house. But he's a cranky boy (ngl I prefer that)

Spoiler

 

[Jam86]

i was talking about personality types with my mum the other day and she said it's kinda weird they limit smug, jock, cranky etc to male villagers then the same with female and that they should keep the 8 personalities but allow both male and female villagers to have any personality type

this was really intersting to think about and i'd love a female smug or male peppy aha
not related to my post but still lol

 

[stiney]

Audie should’ve been snooty, Judy should’ve been peppy and Dom should’ve been lazy imo! also I thought O’Hare was lazy for YEARS him being cranky is so weird to me

O'Hare is smug as of New Leaf.

 

[Bioness]

Ribbot and Sprocket being robot jocks, they should be cranky or smug, or if we get an "smart/nerd" personality type, that.

 

[carackobama]

O'Hare is smug as of New Leaf.

I totally forgot about that as I’ve never had him in my town! I saw him listed as cranky somewhere the other day and found it so strange, it makes total sense they’ve changed it

 

[Heartcore]

I don't personally feel like Judy should be snooty. I think she would fit in better as a peppy or even an uchi. I'd also say Muffy would suit being a snooty better than an uchi.

 

[Crash]

-

 

[marea]

Beardo have no bussines acting smug, he should be cranky imo. I actually like that some of the villagers dont fit the expectaions of what their assigned personalities should look like, Dom for example.

 

[TortimerCrossing]

My boyfriend thinks little Scoot shouldn't be a jock, I painfully disagree.

(come on don't you see him lifting that dumbbell!)