Another 'One has to go' Villager poll!

[Lady Sugarsaurus]

My brother has finally picked a dreamie list for his island, but he has one too many.. so he asks, one has to go, who is it? XD
I know he wants to keep Marshall for sure, so I didn't add him to the list but his island he is planning on having a Japanese/Oriental feel if that helps at all.

Who would you kick off this list?

 

[ayeeprill]

I would get rid of one of the normals as four would be too much for even me, the normal villager fan club president.

I'd say Merengue probably is the least fitting for an oriental town. However, the one I dislike most is Celia.

 

[Clock]

Merengue should go because she doesn't fit well with your town theme.

 

[Lady Sugarsaurus]

I would get rid of one of the normals as four would be too much for even me, the normal villager fan club president.

I'd say Merengue probably is the least fitting for an oriental town. However, the one I dislike most is Celia.

I said Celia too, to be honest. haha. But yes, I agree with the themeing Merengue is probably the one that fits the least.

Merengue should go because she doesn't fit well with your town theme.

I agree too, but she is just so gosh darn cute. haha.

 

[senbeiiscool]

My vote is for Merengue or Lily, although I feel like Lily would fit the island theme more...

 

[WynterFrost]

I'm surprised so many have voted Merengue. I remember the days when people would give their right arm for her

 

[senbeiiscool]

I'm surprised so many have voted Merengue. I remember the days when people would give their right arm for her

I mean, she is absolutely adorable, but given the large amount of normals and fitting the theme, Merengue was an easy choice

 

[Lady Sugarsaurus]

I'm surprised so many have voted Merengue. I remember the days when people would give their right arm for her

Same. haha. I adore her, to be honest. XD
But I also get the whole matching his theme thing.

 

[FaerieRose]

I vote for Celia. You can always gift Merengue a kimono or yukata, to help her fit your village theme better. A white sushi chef's outfit might be cute too, as an alternative to her usual chef's outfit. Or the pinafore (which is over a kimono.)

 

[Blueskyy]

I voted Merengue. Too boring for his theme.

 

[Xara]

out of those options, i would either boot merengue or blanche ;w;

 

[Braixen]

Chose Celia, because:
- too many normals! 4 I think?
- she's a bird, which he already has a couple of others! would be nice for diversity :0
- would also boot Merengue if he prefers Celia over her!

hurts cause I like Celia so much, but that's a pretty solid list!

 

[N a t]

Chose Celia, because:
- too many normals! 4 I think?
- she's a bird, which he already has a couple of others! would be nice for diversity :0
- would also boot Merengue if he prefers Celia over her!

hurts cause I like Celia so much, but that's a pretty solid list!

This comment is quite literally the same reasoning I have so I'm quoting it lol

 

[Halloqueen]

I would get rid of one of the following: Merengue, Chevre, or Celia. The rest feel like they fit the stated theme more except Sprinkle but Sprinkle is adorable and precious and I will do her no harm. Which of those would have to be up to him though. Personally? Chevre, but Braixen in the post above has a fair point that Blanche and Julia have the bird aspect covered so Celia might make more sense to get rid of.