I love them both and both have the kawaii eyes that I love on horse villagers, but I'm torn as to who will be the snooty villager that replaces Vivian. I mean Vivian is cool, but I never fall in love with wolves like I do horses. I have Annalise, Cleo, and Vivian amiibo cards so it isn't a huge deal, but still who should I move in?
Cleo is the only female horse that I like, so I'd choose her. Not to say Annalise isn't kawaii/cute (I had her at one point) but the color scheme of Cleo edges out Annalise or any other female horses to me
i love Cleo's appearance so much
but if you want to go for the "underhorse" so to speak, Annalise is the horse for you... from what i can tell (she's less common than Cleo post-update)