An Introduction to Villager "worth"

[TamaMushroom]

I think based off of stuff I've seen on here there are some villagers higher than others should be on the list and the Extremely popular is all good except for Colton really. There are some like Astird that I haven't seen anyone want and then there are people have wanted Drift and he's on the bottom.

 

[You Pikachu!]

Pietro should be in the Tippy Top.

 

[Isabella]

You forgot about Tier 4: Beardo's tier. I have yet to see anyone's dream list contain Beardo, and I saw a thread devoted entirely to ridiculing him.

beardo is perfect

 

[ben_nyc]

wat is this ridiculous nonsense

Well, that was my first impression too- & I read every single post here. But I credit richu's intent; the concept can grow into something useful like source material for the Animal Crossing community, & while I don't participate in it, Mayors actively searching (trading, aiding each other) for their Dream villagers is a positive aspect of the game & its players.

What needs to be done:

Opinions are tossed around here w/out any merit... the good news is, these users are at least very involved in Dream Villager acquisitions (so most of what's suggested here isn't waaay off base), likely thanks to the efforts of Chaoskitten.

Two polls need to be created-

1. One indicating which villager belongs to which Tier.

2. And another listing by popularity, where a villager Ranks within their given Tier.

Good luck, Richu!

 

[Farobi]

We need to make a separate thread related to this, but with the whole community's concensus of what villager goes to what tier. (it needs to be separated to A, B, C ranks imo...)

 

[BellGreen]

We should actually base is on everyones' opinion. I actually disagreed with a few of them

 

[ben_nyc]

We should actually base is on everyones' opinion. I actually disagreed with a few of them

No, that's madness (or else you'll be debating w/ tons of people). It must be ranked by popularity! =)

 

[Napoleonic]

beardo is perfect

I love Beardo.

 

[ChaosKitten]

The picture hurts my brain, lol. I find it difficult to find animals unless they're at the very top. *derp*

 

[lena]

I think it will be good to make a text-only list besides this picture one. I find it hard to look for certain villagers out of many thumbnails! Anyway I feel that monkeys should be put further down, and I don't remember seeing Flurry, Shep, Tangy, Merengue, Diana as extremely popular.. Apple should be higher up though, about the same as Hamlet. That's just my opinion

 

[Jinglefruit]

Pashmina is very popular? Whitney isn't top? Tia is top?

I second this entirely! Same with Colton being so high - I'd love to have an all horse village on my Alt town, but he is one of the 3 not invited. I think most of the Deer should be upped as well, they seem to be the most popular species and most dream lists I see have 2 deer listed. ~ but maybe I notice it more because I'm aiming to have 6 in my main town. =P

I think Papi should be higher, I haven't seen anyone with a complaint over him. And I couldn't find Ed at all, but that might just be the terrible pixels. ~ I vote either a typed version or just overlap villagers/ make the table wider and use better images.

 

[JellyBeans]

Omg yay Biskit is popular. I can probs swap him for one of my dreamies when he moves in

 

[PinkWater]

How is Chevre not popular? She's like, the cutest goat! Or does no one like goats now.

 

[Elaine]

I second this entirely! Same with Colton being so high - I'd love to have an all horse village on my Alt town, but he is one of the 3 not invited. I think most of the Deer should be upped as well, they seem to be the most popular species and most dream lists I see have 2 deer listed. ~ but maybe I notice it more because I'm aiming to have 6 in my main town. =P

Pashmina is popular but I didn't think by that much. Also, I love Colton but I didn't think he was that high either..

Whitney should be high too though I'm not sure how much she competes with fang. Tia I can see being quite popular but not at the top. Something you need to take account of is that there's only so many of one type. The reason why certain lazies are extremely popular is because they the 'best looking', 'cutest' etc of their type. Most people want a diversity in having one of each type due to PWP's..

Anyway I feel that monkeys should be put further down, and I don't remember seeing Flurry, Shep, Tangy, Merengue, Diana as extremely popular..

Minus Tangy, the ones you listed are EXTREMELY popular. Not sure where you got that from.. they're very popular on all 3 units, TBT, Reddit, & Gamefaqs.

Monkeys were definitely popular before, being Japan exclusive and all, but now I think they've lost a bit of their merit some of them like Monty seem odd to be second highest, though I do understand Nana being there because everybody usually loves the Normal type (they're so sweet and agreeable, hard not to like!), plus she's pink which is usually another popular factor, as well as she's very cute too.

 

[Smile Dog]

Move Tangy down one and put Lucky on top!

 

[Zerigan]

Don't you think Olivia should be higher?

EDIT

You forgot about Tier 4: Beardo's tier. I have yet to see anyone's dream list contain Beardo, and I saw a thread devoted entirely to ridiculing him.

;_; i love you, Beardo..

 

[Gizmodo]

Seeing as Fang can usually be given away for free, and theres not much interest, yet Whitney goes for millions
it all just doesnt make sense lol

 

[Pidjiken]

Whitney is in high demand all her auctions go past 10 mil here. She's tier 1 if not tippy top.

 

[Zebrarella]

According to this, Hopper is fairly popular.... Hmmmm anyone want him cuz i have him AND I HATE HIS EYES!!!

 

[Zebrarella]

Haha, ye I saw that thread also... To be honest I thought it was kinda funny..... Y