Always seeing the same villagers on mystery islands

[sfelix]

ive had marina and merengue repeats aswell?? at this point it should be a conspiracy theory.. but in all seriousness, i think the problem stops if u time skip a few hours back or forwards?? or at least for me it does

That makes sense actually. I heard somewhere (anecdotally mind you) that certain villagers come out of their house at certain times of day so going to the mystery island at that time of day apparently increases the chance you will see that villager.
Haven't found any evidence to back this up though.

 

[Eevees]

I've had this problem alot and recently a friend has just been getting me my harder find dreamies they have better luck! They got Judy and now they are saving Raymond for me lol. They aren't too into animal crossing but dont mind that I am!