I like Phoebe more only because i've experienced her more. The other two are decent villagers though and I have nothing against them I just prefer Phoebes whole look and vibe to them. I'm actually planning on moving her into town soon.
I can't decide between Agnes and Pashmina! Agnes was my first uchi and I've had plenty of fun with her when she lived in my town, while Pashmina is just really adorable.
Phoebe's okay, but she is probably one of my least favourite uchi villagers. I want to like her, but I just don't feel that strongly about her as Agnes and Pashmina.
I say Agnes because I have had her in NL and she is an amazing villager to have. She is a uchi so she has that "big brother" personality and is always caring for the mayor of whatever town shes in. Her room style is also very gorgeous and sleek looking.