A villager you didn't expect to be popular and one you thought would?

[Isabella]

I didn't think whitney would be so popular, since my WW game I was never a fan of her and she was kinda mean LOL. Her design isn't that bad, it's just plain to me. I've seen her go for so many bells before.

And I thought felicity would be more popular, I think she's the cutest cat besides Rosie :3

 

[bluegoat14]

I didn't expect Flurry to be popular... I'm not a fan of her design.

I was shocked that Margie isn't popular. She was in the movie!

 

[Naiad]

I didn't expect Marshal to be a tier 1. I assumed he was Tier 3-4.

I'm surprised that Blanche isn't in Tier 1 or 2. In my opinion, she has one of the best snooty designs. Her original shirt suits her really well.

 

[Stalfos]

I always thought Savannah would be more popular, and I was quite surprised to see that Rosie was so very popular.

 

[QoQ]

I always thought Savannah would be more popular, and I was quite surprised to see that Rosie was so very popular.

Yea I think Savannah is underrated. She has one of my favorite house exteriors.

 

[Adventure9]

My goodness, the villagers I voided before I knew they were popular ;-;

I voided Molly, Flora, and Daisy. (not sure how popular Daisy is...)

I thought Ken and Hans would be a little more popular. :l

*oh, and Ribbot. I liked him, but it was time for him to move on

 

[Geoni]

I didn't expect Fauna to be popular, she's so plain.

I'm surprised that Lionel is considered bottom of the barrel. He's got a great look for the smug personality and one of my favorite villagers.

 

[QoQ]

I didn't expect Fauna to be popular, she's so plain.

I'm surprised that Lionel is considered bottom of the barrel. He's got a great look for the smug personality and one of my favorite villagers.

I'd really like Lionel if he was cranky (I think the voice would suite him a lot better....)

 

[Geoni]

Yeah I think in general the cranky voice should have been shared with the smug characters.

 

[QoQ]

Yeah I think in general the cranky voice should have been shared with the smug characters.

So true...

 

[Locket]

Bob

 

[IncendiaryPyro]

I never knew Molly was popular. I honestly think she looked really gross. I find it hard to believe that Hamlet or Peanut aren't popular. Both are fantastic villagers.

 

[QoQ]

I never knew Molly was popular. I honestly think she looked really gross. I find it hard to believe that Hamlet or Peanut aren't popular. Both are fantastic villagers.

I don't like any of the ducks at all other than Bill. Just cause he looks cute, funny and his name is Bill lol.

 

[PaperCat]

Gaston and Eugene I didn't care for at first, but they are growing on me.

Im kinda (and sorta not) surprised Buck isn't more popular. He is hilarious.

 

[LindseyKate04]

I didn't expect Lolly to be so popular! Don't get me wrong, I think she's absolutely adorable. But every other Tier 1 villager fits under one of these three categories:

1) has something cool/unique about them (ex: Merengue or Ankha)
2) is one of the new or rare species (ex: Diana or Marina)
3) was in the movie

I don't know, maybe it isn't strange to anyone else. And the fact that Kyle isn't at least a Tier 2 is really surprising to me. I guess Kyle and I are both too punk rock for everyone (; hahah