Witch/Moon/Fairy Themed Island: Pecan or Tasha?

[Gleo]

I recently restarted my island and the theme is witch/natural fairy/moons.

Island residents:
Kiki (normal)
Raymond (smug)
Lucky (lazy)
Beau (lazy)
Fuana (normal)
Stitches/Pudge (lazy)
Julian (smug)
Fang (cranky)
Muffy (sisterly) searching for
Pecan or Tasha (snooty) pending

I can't decide between Pecan or Tasha! Please vote for who fits best, thanks! Any other suggestions are greatly welcomed too.

 

[Millysaurusrexjr]

Oh gosh they are both super cool, I am voting Pecan tho because she's a babe

 

[Aurita]

My vote is for Tasha bc her house looks more witchy! She has a black & white theme and a black rose bed o: plus Tasha with a black witch hat would look great imo

here’s pics of her house (not mine):

Spoiler

 

[deana]

From the options I would pick Pecan because I love her so much.

But if you are looking for a snooty squirrel Blaire might be worth considering too? She fit's the black/white/gray colour scheme a lot of your other villagers have.

 

[Fye]

Love them both but Tasha fit better in my town theme-wise and I think she would look great in yours! Her almost-grayscale color scheme and orange eyes make her perfect for a witch theme and honestly she would fall under moon-ish too. And if you need a peppy I HIGHLY recommend Ruby! She's the adorable moon bunny so her house is literally all starry/space themed furniture + the moon in the middle

 

[Gleo]

From the options I would pick Pecan because I love her so much.

But if you are looking for a snooty squirrel Blaire might be worth considering too? She fit's the black/white/gray colour scheme a lot of your other villagers have.

Oh! I thought Blaire was normal honestly but she is indeed a snooty. I'll add the "blair witch" to the poll heh

 

[deana]

Oh! I thought Blaire was normal honestly but she is indeed a snooty. I'll add the "blair witch" to the poll heh

OMG I had not even actually made that connection

I changed my vote to Blaire! I feel like she's kind of a good mix between Pecan and Tasha in a way?

Good luck with picking a new villager

 

[Toska]

I went with Tasha! I think her house and looks fit your town theme much better.

 

[Xara]

both are lovely but i voted for tasha; i think she’d fit the “witch” part of your theme nicely!

 

[TaylaJade]

I like Pecan better (I’m biased though. She was/still is my Wild World friend!) but I think Tasha suits your theme better, especially with her cool house.

 

[Gleo]

Thanks so much for voting everyone! As some voters pointed out I do have a black/white theme going on with my villagers that I had not noticed. With that I have acquired both Blaire and Tasha since they both fit the colour scheme and have rose bed house (one being more natural and one being more gloomy). I'll let time and getting to know them both decide who will be a permanent resident! The other with be moved to the second switch or given away to someone who really wants them!