I'm gonna include villagers that aren't in New Leaf, to make this easier for myself..
Alligator -
Boots (a great villager who I wish was in New Leaf, but he'd make a great jock, definitey better than Sly)
Anteater -
Olaf (he looks like MJ and he definitely suits the smug personality)
Bear -
Charlise (she's so green! How can you not love her <3)
Bird -
Jacques (a DJ bird, who's freakin' epic.. I love him to bits, a great villager)
Bull -
Angus (the only decent bull who isn't named Stu.. He's cool)
Cat -
Tom (one of my favourite all time cats.. He's so cranky, but so cute.. TAKE THAT KABEWKI)
Chicken -
Goose (one of the only chickens in WW I loved, and he's been in so many of my towns.. I love him so much, it's a shame he's a jock, 'cos he doesn't really suit that personality, buthe's still cool <3)
Cow -
Patty (don't be fooled, I don't like cows, but she's the best of a bad bunch)
Cub -
June (the sweetest thing ever, she's so cute! I wish she was in New Leaf so much! I love her eyes, her colouring, the little flower in her hair.. She's so epic, one of my favourite villagers of all time)
Deer -
Erik (Erik pipped Fauna to the post.. He's one of my favourite lazies of all time, and one of my favourite villagers.. I knew as soon as I saw him that he was epic and that I HAD to have him.. He's amazing, he's so cute, so lazy, and has a great house inside and out)
Dog -
Butch (this cranky dawg reminds me so much of one of my favourite Pok?mon - Houndoom.. A great, underrated villager)
Duck -
Joey (my favourite villager of all time for 8 years was beaten when New Leaf came out, but I still love him to pieces.. He was one of my first ANimal Crossing friends, and I love him so much.. He's one of the greatest villagers ever, and needs more love! Joey's just amazing.. I love him so much, and I can't wait to see him again in the next game)
Eagle -
Celia (beating Apollo by a whisker is Celia, she's epic, and so sweet, one of the best Normals)
Elephant -
Tucker (not quite an elephant, but that's what makes me like him so much, he's epic, and needs more love, he deserves more popularity, especially since he's the only elephant with tusks)
Frog -
Henry (the first Smug, other than Eugene, to really jump out at me.. He's so sweet, and should really be lazy, but he's one of the best smugs, and I adore him, it broke my heart when I had to let him go)
Goat -
Gruff (a villager I didn't care much for in the beginning, really grew on me when I had him in my town.. He's a great villager who's overlooked, and more green <3)
Gorilla -
Rocket (anyone who knows me knows that I adore this girl, she's the best Uchi hands down, and I love her tons.. She was the only villager besides Lyman who really grew on me being in my main town after me having a very neutral opinion towards her originally.. Her being a superhero makes her even more epic, but I love her to bits, too underrated)
Hamster -
Hamphrey (I hate hamsters, but Hamphrey's kinda cool)
Hippo -
Rocco (more green, the only hippo in WW, and he's the only hippo I'd ever consider, but he's epic too!)
Horse -
Roscoe (one of the first villagers I ever met, Roscoe, was a great villager, who epitomised the cranky personality.. And is basically the only horse I like, but I haven't seen him in NL at all! D: )
Kangaroo -
Astrid (one of the best snooties, and has a phenomenal design.. So much so that she's the only kangaroo I like, too epic, really grew on me, which surprised me 'cos before I hated kangaroos)
Koala -
Eugene (with Sydney incredibly close behind.. Eugene, the first new villager that I knew I absolutely had to have, he's amazing, in every sense of the word.. Epitomises the Smug personality, he has shades, he's so freakin' awesome! New Leaf was a good game for Koalas, after the lousy ones of WW.. He's incredible, my favourite villager of all time, and if I ever lost him, my heart would shatter..)
Lion -
Elvis (not an incredible villager, but cool nonetheless, unh-hunh)
Monkey -
Simon (one of my favourite lazies of all time, and the only villager in my CF town, besides Goose, who I really, truly loved.. I discovered very few villagers in CF, but Simon grew on me so quickly.. So cute, such a great house.. I love him so much)
Mouse -
Rod (Mr. Nostalgia himself, the first villager I ever met in Animal Crossing was Rod.. He fits the jock personality to a T with that headband and his little outfit.. He's so amazing, and he's purple! One of my favourite colours.. I love him so much, so much nostalgia)
Octopus -
Marina (one of my favourite normals, apart of my initial 8 villagers in WW.. She was always so sweet, I loved her house, despite it being pink, I loved her Soulful KK playing, and she was so nice to everyone in town)
Ostrich -
Phil (a villager who I have loved since the beginning, he's epic, and I knew I had to have him in at least one of my towns.. He's really epic, and deserves more love, some people don't even know he exists, which is disgraceful, because he's amazing!)
Penguin -
Boomer (a villager who really grew on me in New Leaf, it broke my heart to let him go the first time, but he's back now and I love him more than ever.. I love pingus, and it's so fun how he's a penguin, so he can't fly.. But he's a pilot, so he can

.. I loved that twist about him)
Pig -
Hugh (so blue, but those alternating eyes kinda creep me out, but I hate all other pigs, so)
Rabbit -
O'Hare (the very first Smug I ever had, he's so epic.. That little hat, and I love how he covers it with an even bigger hat for New Year.. But he's amazing, he deserves the love he gets, but still deserves more.. Definitely better than Marshal & Julian
Rhino -
Hornsby (one of the original GC villagers who I've loved forever, I love rhinos, I love blue, I love lazy villagers.. Hornsby ftw. I wish he was in NL so much, I'd snatch him up in seconds.. I want him for the next game more than anyone else.. He needs to be there)
Sheep -
Curlos (he's always stood out to me as being one of the very few male sheep, Woolio was epic, Gen sucked and Pietro's worse.. But Curlos is epic, looks like a real sheep, and the smug personality makes him so much cooler..)
Squirrel -
Pecan (a tough choice between her and Nibbles.. Pecan was the third starter I had in WW, and that's one of the reasons I love her so much, she was one of the first villagers to move into my current NL main town, and I was heartbroken when she left me.. But she's still in my WW town, and I love her to pieces.. Needs more love and recognition)
Tiger -
Bangle (always standing out as the only female tiger until NL.. This bengal tiger was epic from the get-go.. When I let Nibbles leave, I knew Bangle was the one to replace her.. She's so epic, and I had her in my town for ages, but I lost her recently, I was heartbroken.. But I'm gonna get her back in my Pok?mon town.. I miss her already, but she'll live on in my memories!)
Wolf -
Chief (my favourite cranky, is definitely more of a fox than a wolf.. He's always so crafty and scheming in his house, like Crazy Redd.. He always comes out with the funniest lines and I wish he was in my main town, but I had him in my last two main towns that corrupted, so I wanted to try someone new)
Phew.