I'll start - My vote would definitely go to Gruff. I had no previous knowledge of him before he walked into my campsite(Igloo at the time) 2 years ago. I liked the uniquity of his fur color. Green is a rarity to see on any villager, it's mainly neutral colors and pink. I talked with him for a bit and gave him a chance. Now he's become one of my favorite crankies, along with Walt, Monty & Cyrano.
Yeah actually I like Pashmina as well as a close second. I had her in my town but then misfortune came upon her and compelled her to make a break for it during my inactive period Although I like Canberra a lot as my current uchi.
I absolutely adore Gruff!!! He is one of my favorite crankies for sure!
I'd have to say I can't choose a favorite between Kidd, Gruff and Pashmina. I've had all the goats except Velma, so instead of letting one of them down I voted for her so Velma wouldn't be at zero.
Kidd is a gentleman hipster goat. Pashmina is classy from the Upper East Side with a history of being the tomboy in prep schools. And Gruff is totally from Star Trek. He's an alien goat for sure from some far away galaxy. He has lived a long, long time, yet stays young playing drums in his retro shack.
This poll made me realize I've had four of the six goats in my town so far--and none of them were planned. Currently, I have Velma and Pashmina, and I've previously had Kidd and Nan. My favorite goat is Kidd, and Chevre is my runner-up (I had her in City Folk before).
Chevre is one of my starters in my new town and I love her sooo much. She's so adorable and sweet and the only cute villager from my starting set. I love the innocent white lamb look she's got. I also have Pashmina now, and I think her design is so pretty but still natural.
I did a lot of plot-resetting when trying to choose my smug villager, attempting to get Chadder. Kidd kept trying to move in over and over, and I wish I'd let him now; I accidentally ended up with a villager I absolutely did not want, and now that I've looked closer at Kidd's design, it's not flashy, but I like it and I mostly like goats. I'm year of the goats, so I love them! -sigh- Maybe one day...
I haven't had Nan before, but I love her design as a cute black goat! If she were in my town with Chevre, they'd be such cute best friends. And then maybe Pashmina and Kidd would have a little romantic flirting relationship as the more mature goats of the group, hahaha. I think that'd be so cute.