Who should Willow replace? (Closed because I got impatient with the card games)

[Livia]

Willow is in my campsite and I really want her to move in. I have 3 normal villagers so I think she should replace one of them, but I love them all so I can’t choose. Sydney is my only villager who likes to sing. I love finding her in random places singing and dancing. I like Fauna because I also have Deirdre and it’s fun having two deer. Ellie is just cute and I love her house interior. Ellie did ask to move out yesterday though and I was considering it, but then I panicked and said no.

 

[Pintuition]

I voted for Sydney to move! Honestly all three of them pose a tough choice, they're all great. I feel like Sydney would be the cheapest to move back in if you wanted her in the future (to buy on noozazon, etc.) so that's why I chose her. There's just something about the Koala villagers I don't jive with!

 

[Fye]

I chose Ellie because I love Fauna and the idea of her beings buds with Deirdre is so sweet, and if Sydney is your only singer then that's enough reason to keep her around, so Ellie was the only option left to me. Also Willow is so cute, congrats!

 

[Lavamaize]

I chose Ellie. Also, I think it's awesome your having Willow move in! She's a great villager and is one of my favorites in the game!

 

[WaileaNoRei]

This post is crazy familiar for me, what a strange coincidence. I had willow yesterday in my campsite (I’ve always wanted her!) and one of the villagers I thought of letting her replace was fauna, because I have 3 normals. Also, Sydney recently became a dreamie for me!
Alas, I was not able to play until the evening and willow defeated me! I had to give up
so I voted for Ellie, cause obviously I have a bias toward the other two

hope you have better luck than me!

 

[Livia]

She kept suggesting the wrong villagers and I got tired of restarting and doing the card game over and over. The last time she suggested Tutu, so I agreed to that. Now I won’t have a peppy villager, but I can try to get Ellie or Sydney to move out next time.

 

[Khaelis]

I picked Ellie, because out of the three you listed you seemed the least attached to them. You DID consider letting them leave, but only kept them due to panic.

 

[Livia]

I wanted to choose Ellie, but I don’t like the card game.

 

[Hanami]

Congrats on getting Willow! She's so sweet

I voted for Fauna. Personally, I often don't feel attached to someone if I'm mainly keeping them for being the same species as someone else (if that's what you were trying to imply). fauna's house in acnh reminds me of a pepperoni pizza

Unexpectedly, Sydney became a favorite and when she moved out of my island, I felt her absence. Like you, she was my only villager who liked to sing. And it was actually Ellie who took her place

Also here's a photo I took of this cutie!