who should my 10th villager be?

[gothgf]

Erik or Stitches? I'm attempting a sort of goth halloween theme with my town, most of my villagers fit that theme while some just kinda match the autumn aesthetic. Erik would just match autumn but Stitches is very halloween fitting. I really like Erik but I feel like I need more halloween villagers! I can't decide

right now I have or am planning to have:
-Muffy (my fave goth icon)
-Amelia (also goth)
-Lucky (he's a mummy!)
-Kyle (my ultimate fave but also autumn matching)
-Roscoe (goth)
-Vesta (very halloween fitting she looks kinda like a ghost)
-Tabby (she looks cutely spooky to me)
-Carmen (to me she matches autumn)
-Rod (he's a pirate!)

so who do you think would fit in better? Erik or Stitches?

edit: thank you everyone who voted! I've decided to go with Stitches!

 

[loglady]

Hmm... I really like Erik too, I think he's adorable! He could definitely fit with the theme of your town. I think you have enough Halloween-esque villagers for you to be able to add him into the mix.

Personally, I would go with Erik, but it's really all up to you and what you would like! I think you should choose the villager you like the most and you're happiest with, whether it be Stitches or Erik.

Your town sounds really cool, by the way, good luck!

 

[krystillin]

I think stitches would go well. Like a cuddly Frankenstein

 

[FoxFeathers]

Erik to me is more "winter" than fall. Stitches is my vote for halloween.

 

[Mayor Kera]

My vote goes to Stitches.

 

[Captain Avian]

Stitches would probably fit better with your theme imo ^-^

 

[Dracule]

Seems that so far there’s a preference for Stitches. Buuut... I would say go for Erik! I have him in my town and he goes so beautifully with the autumnal backdrop. He’s my favorite villager and definitely has my favorite house exterior too. Very woodsy, cozy, and fits with spring, autumn, or winter seasons.

On another note, I’m happy you’re picking Carmen! I also have her and she’s so cute; she actually reminds me of a Sanrio character because of her design! I think you have mostly Halloween-themed or goth-themed villagers, so it wouldn’t be strange to say, have Erik, Kyle and Carmen to give you a better sense of autumn in your town. :>

If you personally feel a desire towards Stitches because he is very “Halloween-looking,” then I would say go with him. It’s important that you’re truly content with your villager choice. (^-^)

 

[fiirefly-crossing]

Both are great choices, but i'd lean more towards Stitches cause he's super cute!

 

[Sothe]

I would definitely go with Stitches over Erik, although I love both of them. I just think Stitches would fit the overall theme of your town better, and I typically associate Erik with winter-themed towns moreso than fall/autumn.

 

[gothgf]

thank you everyone who voted! I've decided to go with Stitches!