Who should I replace?

[Taj]

I have seven dreamies and is about to receive my eight tomorrow. The problem is, I have ten villagers so I would have to get rid of one. I don't have the heart to get rid of one of these villagers so I will leave it to you to decide. Oh yeah, and I will be selling/giving away the villager I decide to replace to a loving home, in case you're wondering. But please DON'T vote for them just because you want a shot for them. I want your honest opinion.

Rosie: Although I never intended to like Rosie because I kinda hate the peppies and my favorite peppy is Cheri. Also, she trampled all of my blue roses! (Blue cat named Rosie tramples blue roses= suicide ). However she has really grown on me and hangs out on the beach which is fun. And she talks to everybody which is really entertaining. In terms of frienship, I think she will give me her picture because she came to my house uninvited. However I'm not completely sure because I've only had her for three weeks.

Elmer: He is not a dreamie either, and he's always wants to come to my house like a perv but Elmer has a lot of sentimental value to me. He is my best friend, the first villager to give me a picture without april fools and all that but the biggest fear of replacing him is that I will no longer have any of my starting villagers, he is the lone survivor. Although he has been rude to me, it would break my heart seeing him go. In terms of friendship, he will definitely give me his picure, because he has before and he is my best friend.

Phoebe: Phoebe is an interesting character. I've only known her for two weeks, so there's no way I will get her picture, and she's really weird. (She wanted to call me "Poopy". WTF?!) However, I really want to give Phoebe a second chance like I did Rosie, because she is a cool looking villager and I would never know if I would become closer friends. But in all honesty, these Uchi's are really freaking me out (especially the creepy looking ones *cough* Muffy).

So there it is. Please, please leave your opinion!

 

[Winkyccat]

Elmer imo because meh villager but if you like him too much to let him go I would choose to boot Pheobe

 

[Raffy]

you're going to have to replace all of them once you get all your dreamies anyway.
I would say out with Rosie.

 

[ams]

It sounds like you would be most comfortable letting go of Phoebe so that would be my advice. However if it were me I'd probably let go of Rosie just based on my personal preference.

 

[The221Believer]

I'd say to say farewell to Elmer. You already have his pic, in terms of progress, and since you'll have to replace them all for your full dreamie set, it might be best to get rid of him first--rip off the lone original villager bandage quickly, instead of delaying.

Phoebe's pretty cool. As an uchi she's awesome (have you gotten the advice about winning fights yet? It's great RL advice too) and as an ostrich modeled to be a phoenix, she's one of the few mythical creatures alongside Drago and Julian. Also her house is super cosy and cute. Hopefully you can come to love her!

 

[The Blood Countess]

Elmer is so cute. I say give Rosie or Phoebe the boot. Probably Rosie. I don't understand why she's popular. At least Phoebe is modeled after a phoenix, which is kind of cool.

 

[Voluptua Sneezelips]

It's a tough decision, but I'm with The221Believer, assuming that you have a full set of 10 dreamies that you eventually want in your town. If you do have a dreamie list of 10, you'll have to get rid of all 3 of your current non-dreamies eventually. For that reason, I'd start with Elmer. If you have fewer than 10 dreamies, then hang onto Elmer and boot Rosie or Phoebe.

 

[Taj]

Thank you for your helpful advice

 

[kkisland]

I say get rid of Phoebe because you know her the least, or Elmer since you've already accomplished getting his picture.

 

[Taj]

I have decided to let go of Elmer. Although it breaks my heart, I feel that it was the best choice, although it still sucks. Thank you all for your input