Well... Looks like this poll has been a bust so far! XD
This kind of poll is so subjective, I find that if you think about it hard enough then you'll end up finding that you had a bias towards one option or the other all along. Listen to your gut on this one <3
I feel like it depends on what kinda personality/gender/species mix you want for your island. It's so personal and you should go with your gut. Ask yourself: who don't I enjoy speaking to everyday, for instance.
(In saying that, I picked Stitches in the poll only because his eyes freak me out...)
I voted for Judy because I'm not a fan and pastell colours and sparkly anime-eyes.
However, something to consider is that she is the only one without an amiibo-card. So if you let her go, it's going to be harder to get her back if you change your mind.
i let fate decide and it took Stitches in the end ;w; i think that's the best outcome after all cause i do have his amiibo if ever want to move him in again!! thanks to everyone to voted and replied to help ^^