I currently don't have a jock either & am trying to get Rudy (he's so hard to get though I've been looking forever!) but I can say that DRIFT is my second favorite, even though he's a frog, and he always makes me smile. He always looks so happy, heh.
Boone was one of my first five villagers. I thought I was going to hate him because I hate gorillas, but I warmed up to him pretty quick. He's a big sweetie!
Poncho! How can you not love the little guy. I find him snoozing on benches and sculptures more than training.
I want Bam in my town :c I'd love him just as much.
I like Bam and Rod. I think they're super cute. I wish I have either one though. (Rod was in my campsite when I had ten villagers! D; )
But I've had Ribbot who I grew to like. I get a little sad when I think about letting him move out, but I know he's in a better town. But right now, I have Axel who is really growing on me.
I'm shocked no one's said Pierce yet! He's such a big sweetie, and I dig the fact he has a buff figure to compliment his personality. Also, his design and color scheme are so pretty! He's essentially a falcon, which makes him even cooler! Drift is my second fav, cuz of his colors and happy face <3