Which villagers shouldn't I want?

[Aestivate]

Yes, this is another villager opinion thread, I know there are way too many out there but I feel like it could change my thoughts and maybe remind me of well, anything.

At the moment I've 12 villager that I would like to have in my town and I'm struggling with picking 2 villagers that won't be my preference anymore. I'm not really into any strict rules about gender/specie/personality balance but feel free to share your opinions on the villagers listed below. Please give me some justification for your choice!

Alfonso >> Male >> Alligator >> Lazy
Melba >> Female >> Koala >> Normal
Coco >> Female >> Bunny >> Normal
Dizzy >> Male >> Elephant >> Lazy
Papi >> Male >> Horse >> Lazy
Kid Cat >> Male >> Cat >> Jock
Shep >> Male >> Dog >> Smug
Kyle >> Male >> Wolf >> Smug
Bangle >> Female >> Tiger >> Peppy
Wolfgang >> Male >> Wolf >> Cranky
Tom >> Male >> Cat >> Cranky
Punchy >> Male >> Cat >> Lazy

Thanks in advance!

 

[ams]

I think we have kind of similar taste in villagers, I love your list!

My advice would be to drop two of the lazies (I know there are way too many good ones). At one point I had about 4 dreamies that were of the normal personality and honestly it gets so boring listening to the same dialogue. I had Melba/Maple/Mitzi/Lolly and I couldn't even remember which one I had been talking to.

It's a tough choice, but I went with Alfonso and Punchy. Alfonso - honestly because I had him and his appeal ended at his funny catchphrase. Once his shirt and catchphrase changed I wasn't that into him anymore. Punchy - you already have 2 other cats and species variety is always good (although I also have 3 cats in my town). I also had Punchy at one point and I just felt that the lazy personality was better suited to the big chubby guys like Dizzy.

I'm also a little biased because I have Melba and Dizzy in my town and I wouldn't give them up for anything.

Hope that helped!

 

[Aestivate]

I think we have kind of similar taste in villagers, I love your list!

My advice would be to drop two of the lazies (I know there are way too many good ones). At one point I had about 4 dreamies that were of the normal personality and honestly it gets so boring listening to the same dialogue. I had Melba/Maple/Mitzi/Lolly and I couldn't even remember which one I had been talking to.

It's a tough choice, but I went with Alfonso and Punchy. Alfonso - honestly because I had him and his appeal ended at his funny catchphrase. Once his shirt and catchphrase changed I wasn't that into him anymore. Punchy - you already have 2 other cats and species variety is always good (although I also have 3 cats in my town). I also had Punchy at one point and I just felt that the lazy personality was better suited to the big chubby guys like Dizzy.

I'm also a little biased because I have Melba and Dizzy in my town and I wouldn't give them up for anything.

Hope that helped!

Thank you for your respons. I also fear for getting bored with 4 lazy villagers, just like you say. But right now I feel like I'm only able to say no to Punchy out of the 4 lazy villagers. I think that's because I've a sort of emotional crush on the somewhat more outstanding facial expressions of Alfonso (〃￣ω￣〃ゞ
It's indeed gonna be a tough choice but again, than you for your help!

 

[TheGreatBrain]

Wolfgang's pretty cool and Melba's adorable.

 

[Lucaboo]

I do t like Afonso, but coco is so cute! Why would t you want her?

 

[Opal]

Alfonso annoys me for some unknown reason :/