Which villagers should I...?

[Mayor Rose]

Not sure if this is the appropriate discussion page but here we go:

I never know which villagers I should void, sell, or giveaway, so I'm asking about my current villagers and what you think I should do with them. (I'm cycling)

Tia
Hamphrey (original)
Gruff (original)
Shari (original)
Colton
Blanche
Marshal

please give me your opinions ;w;

 

[Jacob]

Hey! I recommend voiding/giving away Gruff, Hamphrey, and Shari

If you are looking to make some bells, auction off Marshal and sell everyone else.
If you are looking to make some friends, giveaway Colton, Tia, and Blanche + sell Marshal for 100 btb (unless you wanna give him away as well!)

But for future reference, I recommend you use the "Animal Crossing: New Leaf" board (not trying to mini-mod, just letting you know ;D)

Good Luck!
If you decide to giveaway these villagers however, make sure they go to people who really want them and won't resell for a profit

 

[MyLifeIsCake]

Imo, Gruff is one of the best crankies, don't void him.

Hmm... It looks like you have four white colored villagers, so maybe you can make sort of a White/Black themed town using the color schemed villagers? Just an idea. I would just keep the villagers you personally like, regardless of how popular they are, where they are located, ect.

 

[Reineke]

Word. Gruff is pretty awesome!

One of the things I just learned recently while on a little hunt of my own is that the tier five villagers are harder to get because everyone always voids them. So, its good to check the looking for thread or do a giveaway. Someone wants them-- may not be online at the time, but hey.

 

[Rasha]

I would void Shari, Blanche or gruff

 

[NicPlays]

I would probably try to make some money off Tia and Marshal bye Auction, sell Colton and Blanche, and void the rest.

 

[HHoney]

I think it's great you put up this post - I saw it a few days ago.

Hamphrey and Gruff are two of my Dreamies - Hamphrey was a first 5, but It was hard to get Gruff. I have both, so I can't take them.

Hopefully someone who wants any of your undesirables will see this post and VM you. Otherwise if they are in boxes you might want to look at the LF thread in the villager trading plaza just in case. If no one says they want them, Void them.

Sadly, connecting villagers with their Mayors is really hard logistically.

 

[Mayor Rose]

Ah, ty for all the replies! So, should i just start a cycling thread? or is there already a lot of those? ;w;

 

[Reineke]

You really can't have too many cycling threads. The more cycling threads someone is lurking in, the better their odds of getting their dream villagers. Posting who's in your cycling town in your signature is another good way of doing it because anywhere you post becomes free advertising for you.